My Account List Orders Book Page

The Last Rebuttal Speech

Table of Contents

  • Chapter 1: The Resolution
  • Chapter 2: Cross-Examination
  • Chapter 3: Motion to Reconsider
  • Chapter 4: Constructive Criticism
  • Chapter 5: On the Clock
  • Chapter 6: Point of Information
  • Chapter 7: Unfinished Arguments
  • Chapter 8: The Opening Statements
  • Chapter 9: Time Allocations
  • Chapter 10: Off the Record
  • Chapter 11: Framing the Issue
  • Chapter 12: Burden of Proof
  • Chapter 13: Cross-Fire
  • Chapter 14: Tactical Retreat
  • Chapter 15: Overruled
  • Chapter 16: Hidden Evidence
  • Chapter 17: The Prep Time
  • Chapter 18: Fallacies of the Heart
  • Chapter 19: Calling the Bluff
  • Chapter 20: The Out-of-State Tournament
  • Chapter 21: Point of Order
  • Chapter 22: Closing Arguments
  • Chapter 23: The Judges' Panel
  • Chapter 24: The Final Motion
  • Chapter 25: Grand Cross
  • Chapter 26: The Final Rebuttal

CHAPTER ONE: The Resolution

Clara Vance had spent the last eighteen months perfecting the art of not arguing. It was harder than it sounded, especially when you lived in a college town where someone was always wrong about something, usually loudly and in public. Just this morning, a guy in a Patagonia vest had confidently explained to the barista at The Daily Grind that espresso had more caffeine per ounce than drip coffee, and Clara had simply smiled, taken her iced oat latte, and walked away. Two years ago, she would have pulled up three peer-reviewed studies on her phone before he even got his change. Now, she just drank her coffee and minded her own business.

Peace, she had discovered, was mostly about keeping your mouth shut.

She sat at her favorite corner table on the third floor of the Alderidge University library, a highlighter uncapped in her right hand and a three-hundred-page textbook on constitutional law propped open in front of her. Outside the tall, arched windows, the late February sky was the color of wet slate. A few stubborn patches of gray snow clung to the edges of the quad below, refusing to melt even though spring break was only three weeks away. Clara liked the third floor because it was a designated quiet zone, which meant no one was allowed to debate anything within fifty feet of her.

Her phone buzzed against the scarred wooden tabletop, the screen lighting up with a notification from her university email. She ignored it for a full minute, determined to finish reading a particularly dense footnote about the Commerce Clause, before curiosity got the better of her. She tapped the screen.

The sender was Arthur Pendelton. The subject line read: Urgent. My office. 4:00 PM.

Clara stared at the three words until the screen dimmed and went black. Arthur Pendelton was the head coach of the Alderidge Parliamentary Debate Society, a man who wore tweed jackets with actual leather elbow patches and drank black tea out of a mug that said Cite Your Sources. Clara hadn’t stepped foot in his office since May of her sophomore year, the afternoon she had walked in, handed him her travel binder, and told him she was done.

She checked the time. It was 3:15 PM.

"You look like someone just told you they’re discontinuing iced coffee," Maya said, sliding into the chair across from Clara and dropping a heavy backpack onto the floor with a thud. Maya was Clara’s roommate, a nursing major who possessed the enviable ability to leave her stress at the door of whatever building she was currently exiting.

"Worse," Clara said, turning her phone around so Maya could see the screen. "Pendelton wants to see me."

Maya squinted at the email, then let out a low whistle. "Huh. Did you accidentally leave a trophy in your locker? Wait—do debaters even have lockers?"

"No. And I gave back all the hardware I cared about." Clara locked her phone and slid it into the pocket of her cardigan. "I don't know what he wants. I'm a senior. I'm three months away from graduating, my law school applications are already in, and I haven't touched a flow pad since I was nineteen."

"Maybe he just misses your sparkling personality," Maya offered, pulling a bag of pretzels from her tote. "Or maybe he needs a judge for a local high school tournament. You're good at that. You get to sit in the back of a classroom, look intimidating, and tell sixteen-year-olds why their logic is flawed."

"I don't want to judge high schoolers," Clara said, though the idea was infinitely better than the alternative scenarios currently spinning in her head. "I just want to finish my thesis, survive my capstone seminar, and graduate with my blood pressure intact."

"Well, you won't know until you go." Maya popped a pretzel into her mouth and gestured toward the clock on the far wall. "And if you don't leave now, you're going to be late, which I seem to recall is a cardinal sin in the house of Pendelton."

Clara sighed, capping her highlighter and shoving her textbook into her bag. "If I'm not back by five, send a search party. Tell them to check the basement of the Humanities building."

"If I have to go down into that dungeon, you're buying dinner," Maya called after her in a stage whisper that earned a sharp glare from a guy three tables over.

The walk from the library to the Humanities building took ten minutes, and the wind cutting across the quad made it feel like twenty. Clara pulled her coat tighter around her ribs, ducking her head against the chill. Alderidge was a pretty campus, all red brick and ivy that turned a brilliant crimson in the autumn, though in late February it mostly just looked damp. She took the stone steps two at a time, pushing through the heavy oak doors into the warmth of the building.

The Humanities building smelled like old paper, floor wax, and radiator heat. While the upper floors housed the English and History departments, the basement was reserved for the university’s various competitive clubs—the mock trial team, the student newspaper, and, tucked away at the very end of a dimly lit corridor, the Debate Society.

Clara’s footsteps slowed as she descended the concrete stairs. She hadn't realized how deeply ingrained the muscle memory was until her hand automatically reached for the brass handle of Room B-14. For two years, this basement had been her entire world. She had spent more hours in this windowless room than she had in her own dorm, surviving on cold pizza, energy drinks, and the intoxicating rush of winning an argument.

She knocked twice on the frosted glass of the office door.

"Come in," Pendelton’s voice boomed from the other side.

Clara pushed the door open. Nothing had changed. The walls were still lined with mismatched filing cabinets and framed photographs of past championship teams. A massive whiteboard took up the entire left wall, covered in a chaotic web of dry-erase ink—arrows, acronyms, and half-erased outlines of old cases. The air smelled faintly of Earl Grey tea and stale whiteboard markers.

Arthur Pendelton sat behind a desk buried under stacks of manila folders. His hair was a little grayer than it had been two years ago, and his glasses were perched precariously on the tip of his nose, but otherwise he looked exactly the same.

"Clara," he said, leaning back in his leather chair and gesturing toward the empty seat across from him. "Thank you for coming on such short notice. Please, sit."

"Hi, Coach," Clara said, taking the seat and keeping her backpack in her lap like a shield. "Everything okay? Your email sounded pretty dramatic."

"I am a dramatic man, Clara. It’s an occupational hazard." Pendelton folded his hands over his stomach and studied her for a moment. "You look well. Law school applications all settled?"

"All submitted. Now I'm just waiting for the rejections to roll in."

"Nonsense. With your GPA and your LSAT score, they'll be fighting over you." He reached for his mug, took a slow sip, and set it back down on a cork coaster. "I won't waste your time with pleasantries, though. I have a crisis on my hands, and you are the only person within a fifty-mile radius who can fix it."

Clara’s stomach gave a small, unwelcome dip. "Coach, if this is about judging the regional—"

"It’s not about judging," Pendelton interrupted gently. "It’s about the Whitman Cup."

Clara blinked. The Whitman Cup was the most prestigious collegiate parliamentary debate tournament in the country. Hosted every March in Boston, it was an invitation-only event for the top sixteen programs in the nation. Alderidge had been invited every year for the past decade, and every year, they had come up just short of the final round.

"Okay," Clara said slowly. "Isn't that next weekend? Shouldn't Marcus and Elena be prepping for it?"

Marcus and Elena were the current varsity top pair—two ruthlessly efficient juniors who had taken over the mantle when Clara quit.

Pendelton’s expression darkened. "Marcus came down with mononucleosis on Tuesday. He's currently quarantined in his parents' house in Connecticut, sleeping sixteen hours a day. And Elena, bless her heart, decided that since Marcus couldn't go, she would take the opportunity to fly to Cabo with her sorority sisters a week early for spring break."

"You have a B-team," Clara pointed out.

"My B-team is comprised of two freshmen who, while enthusiastic, still struggle to grasp the basic concept of a counter-plan," Pendelton said dryly. "If I send them to the Whitman Cup, they will be eaten alive before lunch on Friday. Worse, if Alderidge forfeits its spot, we risk losing our automatic bid for next year."

Clara shifted in her chair, the strap of her backpack digging into her shoulder. "I'm sorry, Coach. That really sucks. But I haven't debated competitively in almost two years. I'm rusty. I don't even know what the current meta is."

"The resolution for the Whitman Cup is a classic value-based prompt," Pendelton said, sliding a single sheet of paper across the desk. "No obscure policy jargon. Just pure, unadulterated argumentation. The kind you used to eat for breakfast."

Clara didn't touch the paper, though her eyes dropped to the bold black text printed in the center of the page. This House believes that the pursuit of justice is incompatible with the preservation of mercy.

It was a good resolution. The kind of philosophical, messy prompt that left plenty of room for sharp rhetoric and devastating cross-examinations. For a split second, Clara felt a familiar spark in her chest—the itch to grab a pen, draw a line down the middle of a legal pad, and start tearing the prompt apart.

She forced herself to look away. "It’s a great topic. Truly. But I can't. Even if I wanted to, I don't have a partner. You can't compete at Whitman as a maverick."

Pendelton didn't flinch. "I'm aware of the rules, Clara. Which is why I already secured your partner."

Clara froze. A cold sensation crept up the back of her neck, entirely unrelated to the winter chill outside. "Who?"

Before Pendelton could answer, the heavy oak door of the office swung open.

"Sorry I'm late, Coach," a familiar voice said. "Traffic on Elm Street was a nightmare, and someone decided to double-park a delivery truck right in front of—"

The voice cut off abruptly.

Clara didn't turn around immediately. She didn't have to. She knew the exact cadence of that voice, the slight, effortless confidence in the way he dropped his consonants. She knew it because she had spent two years listening to it across a wooden podium, and another two years trying to forget it.

Slowly, she turned her head.

Julian Reyes stood in the doorway, one hand still resting on the brass knob. He was wearing a dark wool peacoat, his dark hair slightly windswept from the cold, a leather messenger bag slung across his chest. He looked older than he had at nineteen—the sharp angles of his jaw a little more defined, the shadows under his eyes a little deeper—but his dark eyes were the exact same. They locked onto hers, widening by a fraction of an inch before his expression shuttered into something cool and unreadable.

"Clara," Julian said, his voice dropping an octave.

"Julian," she replied, her own voice sounding remarkably steady for someone whose heart was currently trying to beat its way out of her ribcage.

"Ah, wonderful," Pendelton said, beaming as if he hadn't just orchestrated a hostage situation. "Now that we're all here, we can discuss the travel arrangements."

Clara whipped her head back toward the coach. "You're joking."

"I never joke about the Whitman Cup," Pendelton said.

"You can't put us together," Clara said, gesturing vaguely toward Julian without actually looking at him. "We haven't spoken since Chicago. In fact, the last time we were in the same room, he told me I was the most stubborn, self-righteous person he had ever met."

"I believe my exact words were intellectually dishonest," Julian corrected mildly from the doorway, stepping inside and letting the door click shut behind him. "And for the record, you told me I had the emotional range of a toaster."

"A broken toaster," Clara snapped, turning back to glare at him. "At least a working toaster is useful."

"See?" Pendelton said, clapping his hands together once. "The chemistry is still there. You haven't lost a step."

"Coach," Clara said, her voice rising slightly before she caught herself. She took a breath, forcing her tone back into the calm, measured register she had spent eighteen months cultivating. "I am not doing this. I retired. I have a thesis due in April. I have a life that doesn't involve spending forty-eight hours in a Marriott ballroom arguing with people who wear suits to breakfast."

"You have a chance to win the one title that slipped through your fingers," Pendelton countered, leaning forward and resting his elbows on the desk. "And more importantly, you owe me, Clara. I fought the dean for your travel stipends. I wrote your law school letters of recommendation. All I am asking for is one weekend. One final tournament."

Clara opened her mouth to argue, then closed it. He had her there, and he knew it. Pendelton’s letter of recommendation was the crown jewel of her application packet.

She looked at Julian, who was leaning against the filing cabinet with his arms crossed, watching her with an infuriatingly blank expression. "Why are you even here? You quit the team six months after I did."

"I took a sabbatical," Julian said smoothly. "And unlike you, I still enjoy winning."

"You enjoy hearing yourself talk," Clara muttered.

"That too."

Pendelton cleared his throat, drawing their attention back to the desk. "Look, I know you two have... history. I was there in Chicago. I heard the shouting from three hotel rooms down. I don't need you to be best friends. I don't even need you to like each other. I just need you to stand up, deliver your speeches, and bring the Whitman Cup back to Alderidge."

Clara stared at the sheet of paper on the desk. The pursuit of justice is incompatible with the preservation of mercy.

It was a trap. She knew it was a trap, and yet, looking at Julian’s infuriatingly composed face, she realized that walking away now would look a lot like losing. And if there was one thing Clara Vance still hated more than arguing, it was letting Julian Reyes think he had won.

"One weekend," Clara said, her voice tight. "No extra practices. We prep separately, we meet at the hotel on Friday, and when the final round is over on Sunday, we never have to speak again."

Julian’s lips curved into a faint, humorless smile. "Agreed."

"Splendid," Pendelton said, already reaching for a stack of forms. "Now, let's talk about flight itineraries."


CHAPTER TWO: Cross-Examination

Arthur Pendelton did not waste time once he had secured a verbal contract. Before Clara could even process the sheer insanity of what she had just agreed to, the coach had produced two thick manila folders from the bottom drawer of his desk and slid them across the scarred wood.

"Flight 412," Pendelton said, tapping a yellow highlighter against a printed itinerary. "Departs at seven-fifteen Friday morning. That gives you enough time to land at Logan, grab a cab to the Back Bay Marriott, and check in before the opening assembly at noon. Return flight is Sunday at eight-thirty in the evening. Assuming you make it to finals, which, given your track record, I fully expect you to do."

Clara picked up the folder, her fingers brushing the edge of the paper. "Seven-fifteen? Coach, that means we have to be at the airport by five-thirty."

"Debaters do not sleep, Clara. You know this." Pendelton reached into his desk again and pulled out two blue university-issued liability waivers. "Hotel rooms are booked. Separate rooms, obviously. The university’s budget is tight, but I am not entirely devoid of common sense. You’ll each get a per diem for meals, which will be loaded onto your student IDs by Thursday afternoon."

From his spot by the filing cabinet, Julian pushed himself upright and stepped toward the desk to take his folder. He moved with the same unhurried grace Clara remembered, the kind of quiet, controlled energy that used to drive judges crazy because he never looked rattled, even when he was losing.

"What about the prep?" Julian asked, flipping open his folder and scanning the first page. "If we're not practicing together, how are we dividing the casework? Because I'm not walking into round one on Friday morning with two overlapping frameworks."

"I'll handle the affirmative," Clara said immediately, before Pendelton could answer. "You take the negative. We can email our outlines to each other on Wednesday night just to make sure we aren't contradicting ourselves."

Julian’s dark eyes flicked up from the page to meet hers. "And if we disagree on the core definition of the resolution?"

"Then we'll argue about it on the plane," Clara said sweetly. "It'll pass the time."

Pendelton watched the two of them like a man observing a particularly volatile chemistry experiment. He looked entirely too pleased with himself. Before either of them could say anything else, the landline on his desk let out a shrill ring. Pendelton glanced at the caller ID, muttered something under his breath about the dean’s assistant, and stood up, smoothing down his tweed jacket.

"I need to take this in the outer office," he said, grabbing his mug of cold tea. "Sign the waivers, leave them on the blotter, and try not to draw blood before I get back. I'll be five minutes."

The heavy oak door clicked shut behind him, leaving the small, windowless office entirely silent save for the low hum of the radiator in the corner.

Clara didn't look at Julian. She uncapped the cheap ballpoint pen sitting in Pendelton’s mug of spare stationery, pulled the blue waiver toward her, and began filling out her student ID number. The scratch of the pen against the paper sounded ridiculously loud.

Julian didn't move toward the desk. He stayed standing a few feet away, his hands tucked into the pockets of his peacoat, watching her. Clara could feel the weight of his gaze on the side of her face, steady and analytical, the exact way he used to look at an opponent right before he dismantled their entire argument in a five-minute rebuttal.

"You're not going to ask?" Julian said softly.

Clara didn't look up. "Ask what?"

"Why I'm really doing this."

She paused, her pen hovering over the line for her emergency contact. Slowly, she set the pen down and leaned back in her chair, folding her arms across her chest. "I don't care why you're doing it, Julian. You said it yourself—you like winning. And Marcus and Elena bailing gave you a free ticket to Boston."

"That's a lazy assumption," Julian said, tilting his head slightly. "And you were never lazy. Try again."

Clara’s jaw tightened. This was what he did. He turned every conversation into a cross-examination, poking at the weak spots until you gave him the answer he wanted, or until you lost your temper. She had spent eighteen months unlearning the urge to take his bait, and she wasn't about to start now.

"Fine," she said, keeping her voice flat. "You're a senior, just like me. You're graduating in May, and you realized your resume looked a little thin without one last national title. Or maybe you just missed the sound of your own voice echoing in a hotel ballroom."

Julian’s lips twitched, almost—but not quite—forming a smile. "My resume is fine, Clara. I already have a job lined up at a consulting firm in New York starting in July."

The confession landed between them with a faint, unexpected thud. Clara blinked, caught off guard for half a second before she masked it. New York. Of course he did. Julian Reyes had always known exactly where he was going, mapped out to the smallest detail.

"Congratulations," she said evenly. "That sounds thrilling. Lots of spreadsheets."

"Mostly," he agreed. He stepped forward, finally closing the distance to the desk, and picked up the second pen. He didn't sit down, just leaned over the edge of the table to sign his own waiver. From this close, Clara could smell him—cold winter air, wool, and the faint, cedarwood scent of the cologne he had worn since sophomore year. She forced herself not to shift away.

"Now it's my turn," Julian said, his eyes dropping to the paper as he scribbled his signature. "Why did you say yes? And don't give me the speech about owing Pendelton. Your law school applications were submitted months ago. He can't rescind a letter of recommendation."

"It's called loyalty, Julian. You might want to look it up."

"It's called pride," he countered smoothly, capping the pen and dropping it back into the cup. "You walked out of here two years ago and swore you were done. If you said no today, it would look like you were afraid to get back in the ring. Especially with me."

Clara’s heart gave a sharp, traitorous spike against her ribs. She hated how easily he could still read her, even after all this time. Even more, she hated that he was partially right.

"I'm not afraid of you," she said, her voice dropping into the cool, measured register she used when she was about to deliver a devastating point. "And I'm not afraid of the Whitman Cup. I left because I was tired of spending every weekend in a fluorescent-lit room with someone who treated human emotions like logical fallacies."

Julian froze. His hand, still resting on the edge of the desk, curled slightly against the wood. For a fraction of a second, the mask slipped, and something darker—something that looked dangerously like hurt—flashed across his face. Then it was gone, replaced by the familiar, impenetrable calm.

"Right," Julian said quietly. "Because you were always so good at handling your emotions, Clara. Remind me, who was the one who packed her bags at three in the morning in Chicago without saying a word?"

"You told me—" Clara stopped herself, biting down hard on the inside of her cheek. Do not engage. Do not rehash Chicago. Not here, not now.

She stood up abruptly, the legs of her chair scraping loudly against the linoleum floor. She picked up her manila folder, shoved it into her backpack, and zipped it shut with a sharp, decisive yank.

"I have a thesis to write," she said, slinging the bag over one shoulder. "I'll email you the affirmative framework on Wednesday. Don't expect me to reply to anything else."

Julian straightened up, stepping back to let her pass. He didn't try to stop her, didn't offer a parting shot. He just watched her with those dark, unreadable eyes as she pulled the office door open and stepped out into the dim hallway.

Pendelton was nowhere in sight—likely still trapped on the phone in the main department office down the hall. Clara didn't wait for him. She walked briskly toward the concrete stairwell, her boots clicking against the tile.

Behind her, the office door clicked shut, followed by the muffled sound of Julian’s footsteps catching up.

"You're walking too fast," he said, falling into step beside her as they reached the stairs.

"I'm trying to catch the bus," Clara lied. She lived ten minutes away on foot, and they both knew it.

They climbed the stairs in silence, pushing through the heavy oak doors at the top and stepping out into the late February dusk. The sky had darkened to a deep, bruised purple, and the wind cutting across the quad had picked up, carrying the sharp, metallic scent of impending snow. The campus lampposts had just flickered on, casting pools of pale yellow light across the damp brick walkways.

Clara tucked her chin into the collar of her coat, shoving her hands deep into her pockets. Julian walked beside her, his stride effortlessly matching hers. For a few seconds, the only sound was the crunch of their shoes on the salted pavement.

"You're still wearing that thin wool coat," Julian murmured, glancing sideways at her. "It's twenty degrees out."

"It's fine," Clara said tightly.

"You're shivering."

"I'm not shivering. I'm walking briskly."

Julian let out a quiet breath—half-sigh, half-laugh—and looked straight ahead. "Right. My mistake."

They reached the edge of the quad where the pathways diverged—the left leading toward the off-campus apartments near Elm Street, the right toward the newer graduate and senior housing by the river. Clara stopped, turning slightly to face him. Under the glow of the streetlight, the shadows under his eyes looked more pronounced, his dark hair ruffled by the wind.

"Friday morning," Clara said, keeping her tone brisk and professional. "The 7:15 flight. I'll meet you at the gate."

"I'll be there," Julian said. He lingered for a beat, as if he were about to say something else, his jaw working slightly. Then he just nodded. "Have a good week, Clara."

"You too, Julian."

She turned left and walked away without looking back, forcing herself to keep her shoulders relaxed until she turned the corner onto Elm Street and was entirely out of his sight. Only then did she let out the breath she felt like she had been holding since four o'clock.

By the time she climbed the three flights of stairs to her apartment and unlocked the front door, her fingers were numb from the cold. The apartment was warm and smelled strongly of garlic and marinara sauce. Maya was sitting cross-legged on the sagging floral couch, a massive anatomy textbook open in her lap and a bowl of pasta balanced precariously on her knee.

"You're alive!" Maya announced, looking up as Clara kicked the door shut behind her. "I was just about to call campus security. Well, after I finished my rigatoni. So, how bad was it? Are you judging a bunch of sweaty tenth-graders in a high school cafeteria?"

Clara dropped her backpack onto the floor by the door, peeled off her coat, and walked straight into the kitchen. She opened the fridge, stared at the half-empty bottle of cheap pinot grigio on the top shelf, and pulled it out.

"Worse," Clara called out, grabbing a mug from the drying rack because all the wine glasses were in the dishwasher. "So much worse."

Maya twisted around on the couch, frowning as Clara walked into the living room and collapsed into the armchair across from her. "Okay, you're scaring me. Did Pendelton ask you to coach? Because you're twenty-two, Clara, you can't—"

"I'm going to Boston next weekend," Clara interrupted, taking a generous sip of the wine. "For the Whitman Cup."

Maya stared at her. Slowly, she set her fork down in the pasta bowl. "What? Why? I thought you retired. I thought the whole point of senior year was peace and quiet."

"Marcus has mono, and Elena went to Cabo," Clara said, leaning her head back against the cushions and staring up at the popcorn ceiling. "Pendelton guilted me. He brought up the law school letters. And the automatic bid."

"Okay, well, that sucks, and Pendelton is a manipulative genius," Maya said, narrowing her eyes. "Wait. Who are you debating with? You can't do it alone, right?"

Clara closed her eyes. "Julian."

The silence in the living room stretched for a full five seconds.

"Julian," Maya repeated, her voice rising an octave. "As in, Julian Reyes? As in, the guy whose name we haven't spoken in this apartment since freshman year? The guy who made you cry in a Chicago hotel lobby?"

"I didn't cry," Clara said automatically, opening her eyes to glare at her roommate. "I was hyperventilating. There's a difference."

"You were crying, Clara. You called me at two in the morning and I could barely understand you." Maya set her textbook aside and leaned forward, her expression shifting from shock to genuine concern. "Are you out of your mind? Why on earth would you agree to get on a plane with him?"

"Because if I said no, he would have thought I was still..." Clara trailed off, waving a hand vaguely in the air. "I don't know. Afraid of him. Or still hung up on what happened. It's forty-eight hours, Maya. We're not even prepping together. We're meeting at the airport, doing the rounds, and then we're done. Forever."

Maya studied her for a long moment, clearly unconvinced. "And how did it go today? In Pendelton's office?"

Clara took another sip of wine, wincing slightly at the bitter taste. "He's exactly the same. Still arrogant. Still turns everything into a cross-examination. He has a consulting job lined up in New York after graduation, by the way. Apparently, he's doing great."

"Of course he is," Maya muttered. "Guys like that always land on their feet. Look, if you want to call Pendelton tomorrow and tell him you came down with a sudden, tragic case of mono too, I will fully support you. I'm a nursing major, I can forge a very convincing doctor's note."

"I'm not backing out," Clara said, sitting up straighter. A strange, stubborn resolve had begun to settle in her chest, replacing the initial panic. "I'm a better debater than I was two years ago. And honestly? I'd really like to win the Whitman Cup before I graduate. Just to prove I can."

Maya sighed, shaking her head, though a small smile tugged at the corner of her mouth. "You're impossible. You know that, right? You spend eighteen months pretending you don't care about arguing anymore, and the second someone waves a trophy in your face, you're right back in the ring."

"It's not about the trophy," Clara said.

"Right. It's about loyalty," Maya teased, picking up her pasta bowl again. "Just promise me you won't let him get in your head. If he starts pulling that detached, superior-intellect crap, you kick him under the table."

"Deal," Clara said.

She finished her wine, wished Maya goodnight, and retreated to her bedroom. The room was quiet and familiar, lit only by the warm glow of her desk lamp. She set her backpack down on the chair, unzipped it, and pulled out the thick manila folder Pendelton had given her.

She didn't need to look at it tonight. She had a constitutional law reading to finish for tomorrow's seminar, and Wednesday was still four days away.

Still, Clara sat down at her desk, flipped open the folder, and pulled out the single sheet of paper with the tournament resolution printed in bold black ink.

This House believes that the pursuit of justice is incompatible with the preservation of mercy.

She stared at the words for a long time. Slowly, almost without realizing she was doing it, she reached into her desk drawer, pulled out a fresh yellow legal pad, and uncapped her favorite black pen. She drew a straight vertical line down the center of the page, labeling the left side Affirmative and the right side Negative.

It was just a few preliminary notes. Just enough to make sure she didn't embarrass herself on Friday morning.

It had nothing to do with Julian Reyes.


This is a sample preview. The complete book contains 27 sections.