My Account List Orders Book Page

The Bell Unrings at Vespers

Table of Contents

  • Chapter 1 The Silence After Compline
  • Chapter 2 Ashes Returning to the Hearth
  • Chapter 3 The Unwritten Chronicle
  • Chapter 4 Wine Turning Back to Water
  • Chapter 5 The Blind Man's Returned Shadow
  • Chapter 6 Unspoken Vows in the Chapter House
  • Chapter 7 The Healing That Unmade Itself
  • Chapter 8 Candlelight Drawn Into the Wick
  • Chapter 9 The Abbot's Forgotten Name
  • Chapter 10 Footsteps Erased from the Cloister
  • Chapter 11 The Leper's Returning Scales
  • Chapter 12 Ink Lifting from the Parchment
  • Chapter 13 The Bell's Backward Toll
  • Chapter 14 Bread Broken Into Whole Loaves
  • Chapter 15 The Reliquary's Closed Lid
  • Chapter 16 Prayers Unsaid at Nones
  • Chapter 17 The Pilgrim's Departing Steps
  • Chapter 18 Wounds Reopening in the Infirmary
  • Chapter 19 The Choir's Retreating Hymn
  • Chapter 20 Rain Rising to the Clouds
  • Chapter 21 The Novice's Uncut Tonsure
  • Chapter 22 The Miracle of the Shrinking Alms
  • Chapter 23 Dawn Before the Midnight Vigils
  • Chapter 24 The Gate Unlatched from Within
  • Chapter 25 The First Stone Laid in Reverse
  • Chapter 26 Matins Before the World Began

CHAPTER ONE: The Silence After Compline

The silence after Compline was not the usual silence. Brother Thomas knew the usual silence well enough; he had lived inside it for thirty-four years, give or take a few winters when his cough had been particularly loud. The usual silence was a heavy, woollen thing, smelling of damp stone, tallow, and the collective digestion of forty-two men who had eaten boiled turnips at five o'clock. It was a silence that settled downward, like dust on a Psalter.

This silence was rising.

Thomas stood in the north transept, his hands tucked into the sleeves of his scapular, and felt the quiet lifting off the flagstones. It pulled at the hem of his habit. It tugged at the loose skin beneath his chin. Around him, the abbey church of Saint Bartholomew was dark, save for the sanctuary lamp, which hung before the high altar like a drop of blood suspended in oil. The flame did not flicker. It stood upright, rigid as a brass pin, and if Thomas squinted, he could swear the smoke was curling downward into the wick, as though the fire were drinking its own breath.

He blinked, and the sensation passed, leaving only the cold.

In the choir stalls, the other monks were already gone, or perhaps they had not yet arrived. Thomas was never entirely sure anymore which way the hour was leaning. His knees ached, which meant he had either been kneeling for a very long time or was about to kneel for a very long time. Either way, the stone floor was unforgiving. He shifted his weight from his left foot to his right, and the leather of his sandal made a small, sharp thock against the slate—except the sound seemed to arrive a fraction of a second before his heel actually touched the ground.

He looked down at his foot. He lifted it again, very slowly, and set it down. Nothing happened. The stone remained stubbornly mute.

"God's mercy," Thomas muttered, though he kept his voice low. The Abbot had a particular hatred for monks who spoke after Compline. The Great Silence was supposed to be absolute, broken only by the necessary groans of the elderly and the occasional snore from the novices' dormitory. To speak now was to invite a penance of bread and water, or worse, a private lecture from Father Prior on the virtues of the desert fathers, who apparently never spoke at all and lived exclusively on locusts and wild honey. Thomas had never seen a locust in Yorkshire, and he doubted the Prior had either, though the man spoke of them with an alarming degree of familiarity.

Thomas turned toward the cloister door. He needed to be in the dormitory. Everyone else was in the dormitory, or walking toward it, or walking backward out of it—he could not keep the sequence straight in his head, and trying to do so gave him a dull, throbbing pain behind his left eye.

He pushed open the heavy oak door. It swung inward without a creak, which was itself a minor miracle, because the iron hinges had been screaming like dying gulls since the feast of Saint Martin. Thomas stepped into the covered walkway of the cloister and pulled the door shut behind him.

The night air was sharp and smelled of wet wool and woodsmoke. Across the garth, the herb garden was a tangle of black shadows, the rosemary and sage hunched low against the frost. Above the roof of the refectory, the moon hung like a chipped plate, bright enough to cast pale, watery shadows across the paving stones.

Thomas began to walk along the east walk, keeping close to the wall where the wind did not reach. His shadow stretched out behind him, long and thin, and then, as he passed a buttress, it seemed to snap forward, leaping ahead of his feet before shrinking back into his heels. He stopped. He looked behind him. There was no one there. Only the empty arcade of stone arches, repeating themselves into the gloom like a row of teeth.

He walked on, faster now.

The dormitory stairs were at the end of the walk, beside the chapter house. As Thomas approached them, he heard a sound from above: the soft, rhythmic shuffle of forty pairs of sandals moving in unison. It was the sound of the community retiring for the night. Yet as he listened, the shuffling did not grow fainter, as it should have when the brothers reached their straw pallets and lay down. Instead, it grew louder, sharper, more distinct, as if they were all marching backward down the stairs toward him.

Thomas pressed himself against the cold stone of the doorframe and waited.

Nothing came down the stairs. The sound simply reached a peak—a crisp, collective rustle of wool and leather—and then vanished, cut off as cleanly as a candle snuffed with wet fingers.

"Brother Thomas?"

The voice came from the darkness at the top of the landing. It was Brother Julian, the infirmarian, whose knees clicked when he walked and whose breath always smelled faintly of fennel.

"Here," Thomas whispered.

"You are late," Julian said, though he did not sound angry. In fact, he sounded as though he were finishing a sentence he had begun several minutes ago. "The Abbot has already gone to his cell. If he catches you wandering the cloister at this hour, he will have you scraping the moss off the well-head until Advent."

"I was in the church," Thomas said, climbing the stairs. His legs felt strangely light, as if the gravity on the steps had been halved. "I thought I heard the bell."

"The bell?" Julian's face was a pale blur in the gloom at the top of the stairs. "Compline ended an hour ago, Thomas. You were there. I saw you yawn during the Nunc Dimittis. You nearly swallowed your own tongue."

"Did I?" Thomas reached the landing. He had no memory of yawning. He had no memory of the Nunc Dimittis at all, though the words were suddenly sitting on the tip of his tongue, warm and familiar, as if he were about to sing them. Lord, now lettest thou thy servant depart in peace.

"Go to bed," Julian said. He turned and walked away down the central aisle of the dormitory, his knees clicking—tick, tick, tick—in steady time.

Thomas followed him into the long, low room. The dormitory was a cavernous space beneath the timbered roof, divided into narrow cubicles by low wooden partitions. Forty-one monks were already in their beds, or sitting on the edges of them, or standing beside them in the dark. It was impossible to tell which. The air was thick with the smell of unwashed feet, damp straw, and the faint, sweetish scent of tallow from the single night-lamp that hung from the central beam.

Thomas found his cubicle near the far end, beside the window that overlooked the cemetery. His pallet was neatly made, the rough grey blanket folded back at the corner, as if he had just climbed out of it. He sat down on the edge of the mattress. The straw rustled beneath him, a dry, complaining sound, and then settled.

He did not lie down. He sat with his hands on his knees and stared at the opposite wall.

Something was wrong with the night. It was not just the silence, and it was not just the way his shadow had jumped. It was a feeling in the marrow of his bones, a sense that the world had been wound up too tight and was now unspooling, gear by gear, tooth by tooth. He had felt it first three days ago—or was it three days from now?—when he had dropped his wooden bowl in the refectory and watched the spilt broth leap back off the flagstones and into the cup, leaving the floor dry and his tunic spotless. He had told no one. A monk who saw broth leaping upward was either a mystic or a liar, and Saint Bartholomew's had no patience for either.

Beside him, on the other side of the wooden partition, Brother Bede was breathing heavily. It was a wet, rattling sound, the sound of a man whose lungs were full of winter. Bede was eighty-two and had been dying since Michaelmas. Every night, Thomas listened to him rattle, waiting for the moment when the breathing would stop and he would have to fetch Julian to administer the last rites.

Tonight, however, the rattling was different. It was growing clearer. With each breath, Bede's chest seemed to draw less phlegm and more air, the wet wheeze thinning out into a steady, even rasp, like a saw cutting through dry pine.

Thomas leaned his ear against the partition. "Bede?" he whispered.

There was no answer, only the steady, improving rhythm of the old man's lungs.

Thomas sighed and leaned back. He pulled his feet up onto the pallet and swung his legs under the blanket. The wool was cold at first, then rapidly grew warm, as if someone else had been lying there a moment before. He closed his eyes.

In manus tuas, Domine, he thought, trying to anchor himself to the familiar words of the night office. Into thy hands, O Lord, I commend my spirit.

The words did not comfort him. They felt loose, like stones in a wall whose mortar had washed away. He opened his eyes again.

The night-lamp in the center of the dormitory was burning brighter now. Its yellow light reached all the way to the rafters, illuminating the cobwebs that hung like tattered banners from the oak beams. In the aisle, a figure was standing.

Thomas squinted. It was Brother Julian again, though he had not heard the infirmarian's knees clicking back down the room. Julian was holding a small pottery bowl and a linen cloth. He was looking down at the floor, his shoulders hunched, his mouth moving silently.

"Julian?" Thomas whispered.

Julian did not look up. He knelt slowly, placed the linen cloth against the floorboards, and began to wipe. Except there was nothing on the floorboards to wipe. The wood was clean and dry. Yet as Julian drew the cloth across the grain, a dark, wet stain appeared behind it, spreading outward from the center of the aisle until a small puddle of spilled water lay glistening in the lamplight.

Julian stood up, holding the dry cloth and the empty bowl, and walked backward toward the door. His knees clicked—tock, tock, tock—and then he was gone.

Thomas sat up. His heart was hammering against his ribs like a trapped bird. He swung his legs out of bed, his feet hitting the cold boards with a dull thud, and walked over to the puddle. He knelt and touched it with two fingers. It was cold. It was real. It smelled faintly of lavender, the water Julian used to wash the feet of the sick.

"What is this?" Thomas said aloud, forgetting the Great Silence entirely.

From the darkness of the cubicles, no one answered. No one groaned, no one turned over in their straw, no one hissed at him to be quiet. The entire dormitory was held in a breath that refused to be exhaled.

Thomas stood up and looked down the long row of partitions. In the dim light, he could see the shapes of his brothers. Some were lying flat, their blankets pulled up to their chins. Others were sitting up, staring straight ahead, their eyes wide and glassy in the gloom. None of them were asleep. None of them were moving.

A sudden, terrible thought struck him: they were all waiting for Compline to begin.

He turned and hurried toward the stairs, his bare feet slapping silently against the wood. He did not stop to put on his sandals. He did not care about the Abbot or the moss on the well-head. He needed to see the church. He needed to see the sanctuary lamp.

The cloister was brighter than it had been. The moon had risen higher—no, it had sunk lower, toward the eastern horizon, casting a sharper, colder light across the garth. The shadows of the arches were shorter now, pulled tight against the bases of the pillars.

Thomas reached the oak door of the church and pulled it open.

The church was not dark.

A dozen tallow candles were burning along the choir stalls, their flames tall and steady, throwing a warm, golden light over the carved oak misericords. The air smelled of beeswax and frankincense, thick and sweet, as though the thurible had just been swung.

And the church was not empty.

Forty-two monks stood in their stalls, their cowls pulled up over their heads, their hands tucked into their sleeves. They were facing the high altar, where the Abbot stood in his black cappa, his back to the community, his arms raised slightly from his sides.

Thomas froze in the doorway. He was supposed to be in his stall, third from the end on the north side, between Brother Bede and Brother Stephen. He looked at his place. It was empty.

Nobody turned to look at him. Nobody seemed to notice that the door had opened, or that he was standing there in his night-shirt and bare feet, shivering in the draft.

Then, the Abbot's arms dropped.

At the exact same moment, the choir began to sing.

It was not the singing Thomas knew. The notes did not rise from their throats and drift up into the vaulted ceiling to be lost among the stones. Instead, the sound seemed to gather from the corners of the church—from the dark chapels, from the high clerestory windows, from the cold stone beneath their feet—and pour into their mouths.

Amen, they sang, though the word came out backward, a strange, rushing intake of breath that ended in a sharp Nema before they closed their lips.

Thomas gripped the doorframe. His knuckles turned white.

The Abbot turned from the altar, stepped down to the sanctuary floor, and walked backward toward his stall. His movements were smooth, unhurried, and entirely unnatural, like a man being pulled by a rope tied to his spine.

In the stalls, the monks bowed. Then they straightened. Then they sat.

Thomas watched his own empty stall. He felt a sudden, irresistible pull in his chest, a tug as physical as a hand grabbing his tunic. He did not want to cross the nave. He wanted to run back to the dormitory, pull the blanket over his head, and wait for the sun to come up—if the sun ever came up again.

But his feet were already moving.

He walked down the north aisle, his bare heels making no sound on the flagstones. He slipped into the choir, stepped into his stall, and sat down beside Brother Bede.

Bede did not look at him. The old man's eyes were fixed on the Psalter open on the desk before him. His breathing was smooth and quiet, without a trace of the rattle that had plagued him all winter.

Thomas looked down at his own Psalter. The parchment was yellowed and worn at the corners, the black ink sharp against the vellum. He knew this page. It was Psalm 91. Qui habitat in adiutorio Altissimi. He who dwelleth in the aid of the Most High.

He waited for the cantor to intone the next verse.

Instead, the cantor—Brother Martin, a young man with a voice like a cracked bell—opened his mouth and drew in a long, ringing note that ended in a crisp, clean silence.

Around him, the monks were un-singing Compline.

It was the strangest thing Thomas had ever witnessed, and yet, as the minutes passed, a terrifying kind of sense began to settle over it. They were not making mistakes. They were not confused. Every gesture, every bow, every turn of the page was executed with the precision of a clockwork mechanism running in reverse. When they stood for the Nunc Dimittis, they stood together, their habits rustling in a single, sharp sigh. When they made the sign of the cross, their hands moved from their right shoulders to their left, then up to their foreheads, then down to their chests, erasing the blessing from the air.

Thomas tried to join in, to move his lips with theirs, but his tongue felt thick and clumsy. He could only sit and stand and bow a fraction of a second too late, like a novice who had not yet learned the rhythm of the house.

When the final Pater Noster was unsaid—the words retreating into the Abbot's throat until only a faint Amen remained hanging in the air—the candles along the stalls began to grow taller.

Thomas watched the one nearest him. A drop of melted wax slid up the side of the tallow shaft, vanished into the pool at the top, and the wick lengthened, bright and clean, as the flame shrank slightly, settling into a steady, unbothered point.

Then the Abbot gave the signal—a small, sharp clap of his hands that seemed to suck the sound out of the room—and the community turned as one and filed out of the choir.

They walked backward.

Thomas did not walk backward. He stood in his stall, gripping the carved oak armrest, and watched forty-one men glide smoothly down the center aisle, their sandals whispering against the stone, their cowls hiding their faces. They passed through the nave, through the rood screen, and out into the cloister, disappearing one by one into the darkness.

Only the Abbot remained.

He stood at the edge of the sanctuary, his black cappa pooling around his feet, and looked directly at Thomas.

Thomas's breath caught in his throat. The Abbot's face was pale in the candlelight, his eyes deep-set and shadowed. He was not a young man, and the winter had been hard on him; his cheeks were hollow, and his beard was streaked with grey.

For a long moment, neither of them moved.

"You are not going," the Abbot said. His voice was quiet, almost gentle, and it sounded entirely normal—forward, whole, unbroken.

"I cannot," Thomas said. His own voice sounded thin and fragile in the great stone space. "My feet will not go that way."

The Abbot nodded slowly, as if he had expected this answer. He stepped down from the sanctuary and walked toward the choir stalls, moving forward, the way a man was meant to walk. He stopped a few paces from Thomas, his hands folded inside his sleeves.

"It is the silence," the Abbot said. "It has been building since Vespers. I thought we might outlast it if we kept the offices. If we sang the hours, perhaps the hours would stay in their places."

"They are not staying," Thomas said.

"No," the Abbot agreed. "They are not."

He looked up at the sanctuary lamp, where the flame stood rigid as a brass pin. "Do you remember what happened at Nones, Brother Thomas?"

Thomas frowned, searching his memory. Nones was at the ninth hour, in the middle of the afternoon. He remembered the cold wind in the garden. He remembered the bell. "We prayed," he said. "And then we went to the scriptorium."

"Before that," the Abbot said. "In the chapter house."

Thomas shook his head. "I do not remember."

"No," the Abbot said softly. "You wouldn't. None of us will, soon enough. That is the mercy of it, I suppose. Or the curse." He turned his gaze back to Thomas, and for the first time, Thomas saw fear in the old man's eyes. Not the fear of a monk who had broken a rule, nor the fear of a priest who had doubted a doctrine, but the simple, animal fear of a man watching the ground give way beneath his boots.

"Go back to the dormitory, Thomas," the Abbot said. "Lie down. Close your eyes. When the bell rings for Matins, do not answer it."

"If I do not answer it, you will give me a penance."

A faint, dry smile touched the Abbot's lips. "I think, Brother Thomas, that by the time Matins arrives, I will have forgotten how to give a penance. And you will have forgotten how to earn one."

He turned and walked away, down the center aisle, his footsteps steady and unhurried. He did not walk backward. He walked like a man who had decided to meet whatever was coming—or whatever was leaving—on his own two feet.

Thomas stood alone in the choir.

The candles were still burning, tall and bright. The air still smelled of beeswax and frankincense. The silence had settled back into the stones, heavy and woollen once more, as if nothing had happened at all.

He looked down at his Psalter. The page was still open to Psalm 91.

A thousand shall fall at thy side, and ten thousand at thy right hand: but it shall not come nigh thee.

Thomas reached out and closed the book. The leather cover met the pages with a soft, flat thump.

Then he stepped out of his stall, walked down the aisle, and followed the Abbot into the dark.


CHAPTER TWO: Ashes Returning to the Hearth

By the time Thomas reached the cloister, the Abbot had vanished.

There were no footsteps on the paving stones, no whisper of a black cappa brushing against the pillars. Thomas stood in the doorway of the church, his bare feet numb against the threshold, and listened to the night. The wind had died down, or perhaps it had not yet begun to blow. Across the garth, the herb garden lay stiff and silver under the moonlight, the rosemary bushes hunched like small, frozen friars.

Thomas looked down at his feet. He ought to go back to the dormitory. The Abbot had told him to lie down, to close his eyes, to ignore the bell when it rang for Matins. It was good advice, as far as advice went, though Thomas had never been particularly good at ignoring bells. Thirty-four years of monastic discipline had trained his legs to swing out of bed at the first iron clang before his brain was even awake enough to resent it.

Still, he did not turn toward the dormitory stairs. Instead, he turned left, along the south walk, toward the warming room.

The calefactorium was the only room in Saint Bartholomew's where a fire was permitted outside the kitchen and the infirmary, and even then, the Prior guarded the woodpile as if it were composed of splinters from the True Cross. In January, a monk's life was a simple negotiation between his soul and his chilblains. Thomas's chilblains were currently winning.

He pushed open the heavy oak door of the warming room and stepped inside.

The room was dark and smelled of cold soot. The great stone hearth at the far end was nothing more than a black mouth filled with grey, dead ash. There were no candles lit, no monks huddled on the wooden benches. Only the pale light of the moon, filtering through the narrow lancet window, fell across the flagstones in a thin, crooked bar.

Thomas shuffled over to the hearth and sat down on the stone bench beside it. He tucked his bare feet up under the hem of his night-shirt and wrapped his arms around his knees. He was shivering—a deep, rattling shiver that started somewhere in his ribs and worked its way out to his teeth.

"Lord have mercy," he whispered, his breath pluming white in the air.

Except the plume did not drift upward and vanish. It hung there for a second, tight and dense, and then slid neatly back between his lips.

Thomas clamped his mouth shut. He stared at the grey mound of ashes in the grate.

At first, nothing happened. The room was as still as a tomb. Then, very faintly, he heard a sound like dry leaves shifting in a ditch. A tiny, pale spark—no larger than a pinhead—winked into existence near the center of the ash heap. It did not fade. It brightened, turning from a dull, watery orange to a sharp, angry red.

Another spark appeared beside it. Then three more.

Thomas leaned forward, his hands gripping the edge of the stone bench.

The grey dust began to stir. It did not blow away; it drew inward, collapsing upon itself like spilled flour being swept into a pile by an invisible broom. Beneath the dust, black shapes began to emerge—jagged, porous lumps of charcoal that glowed along their edges with a fierce, pulsing heat.

A thin ribbon of smoke appeared, curling downward from the black throat of the chimney. It was thick and bluish, smelling sharply of wet oak and applewood, and it dove straight into the glowing coals, disappearing into them as if the fire were inhaling.

Thomas felt the warmth touch his shins. It was not the gentle, dying heat of a banked fire, but a sudden, eager warmth that pressed against his cold skin like a dog nosing at a closed door.

He did not move. He could not have moved if the Prior himself had walked in with a birch rod.

The coals swelled. Small tongues of yellow flame licked downward from the smoke, wrapping themselves around the black charcoal. As the flames touched the charred wood, the black crust began to flake away—not falling off, but healing over, turning from brittle cinder back into solid, pale-grained oak.

Within three minutes, a respectable fire was snapping in the hearth.

It cracked in reverse—a sharp pop that seemed to pull the air toward it—and the logs settled into a neat pyramid over a bed of bright, steady embers. The light from the flames danced across the whitewashed walls, chasing the shadows back into the corners of the room.

Thomas held his hands out toward the blaze. The heat was real. It soaked into his knuckles, stinging his frozen skin until his fingers throbbed.

"Well," Thomas said to the empty room. "That is certainly one way to save on kindling."

Before the words had fully left him, the door behind him opened.

Thomas jumped, nearly tipping off the bench, and spun around.

It was Brother Cuthbert, the lay brother who tended the abbey's fires and looked after the pigs. Cuthbert was a broad, silent man with a face like a weathered turnip and hands permanently stained the color of walnut husks. He was carrying an empty wicker basket under one arm, and he was walking backward.

Thomas pressed himself against the warm stone of the chimney breast and watched.

Cuthbert glided smoothly across the flagstones, his heavy leather boots making no sound at all—or rather, making a soft, muffled thud just before each heel lifted. He stopped beside the woodbox, bent down, and reached inside.

There were no logs in the woodbox. Thomas had seen it was empty when he came in.

Yet as Cuthbert's large, scarred hands hovered over the box, a split log of seasoned oak leaped up from the hearth—no, not from the hearth, for the pyramid of burning wood was still there. Wait. Thomas blinked. The fire in the hearth had grown smaller. One of the top logs had vanished, and now it was resting neatly in Cuthbert's arms, cold and unburned, with a patch of pale lichen still clinging to its bark.

Cuthbert straightened up, turned—still moving with that eerie, effortless smoothness—and walked backward out the door, pulling it shut behind him.

Thomas stared at the closed door. Then he looked back at the fire.

It was still burning, though it was smaller now, just a modest, cheerful blaze of three logs. The warmth in the room was steady and pleasant, the chill driven entirely from the stones.

"I am losing my wits," Thomas murmured. "Too much boiled turnip. Or not enough."

He sat back down on the bench, though he kept his eyes fixed on the door. He did not have to wait long.

A few moments later, the latch lifted, and three monks walked backward into the room.

Thomas recognized them immediately, even from behind: Brother Stephen, who had sat beside him in the choir; Brother Martin, the young cantor with the cracked voice; and Brother Anselm, the novice master, whose nose was always red from the cold.

They did not look at Thomas. They moved in a tight, silent cluster over to the hearth, arranged themselves on the opposite bench, and held their hands out toward the flames.

For a long time, nobody spoke. They simply sat there, their cowls pushed back, their faces bathed in the orange light. Thomas watched Brother Martin's wet woollen socks—the boy had evidently stepped in a puddle in the cloister—begin to steam. Except the steam did not rise from the wool; it gathered from the air above his ankles and sank into the grey yarn, leaving the socks darker and wetter by the second.

Martin shivered, though he did not seem distressed by it. In fact, he looked rather cheerful.

"It's a hard frost," Martin said.

The words came out slightly clipped, as if he had finished a thought before he began it, yet Thomas understood him well enough.

"Harder than last year," Brother Anselm replied, rubbing his red nose. "The ink froze in the scriptorium before Nones. Brother Luke had to hold his horn over a candle just to finish the rubric on Saint Jude."

Thomas frowned. He looked from Anselm to Stephen. They were talking forward—mostly. Their sentences made sense, even if their movements had that strange, pulled-by-a-string quality when they shifted on the bench.

"Brothers," Thomas said, leaning forward. "Do you not see it?"

Brother Stephen turned his head slowly. His eyes were clear and calm. "See what, Thomas?"

"The fire," Thomas said, gesturing toward the grate. "It was ashes. Just now, it was cold ashes. And Cuthbert—"

"Cuthbert is always late with the wood," Anselm said mildly. "You know how he is. If he isn't asleep in the pigsty, he's arguing with the cellarer about the price of tallow."

"No," Thomas said. "He took the wood away. The fire is un-burning."

Stephen looked at the hearth, then back at Thomas. A faint, patient smile touched the corners of his mouth—the kind of smile one reserved for novices who claimed to have seen the Virgin in the cabbage patch.

"You have been standing in the church too long, Thomas," Stephen said gently. "Your feet are blue. Put them closer to the grate before you lose a toe."

Thomas looked down at his feet. They were, indeed, a rather alarming shade of purple. He tucked them closer to the warm stones, feeling the heat prickle along his arches.

He wanted to argue. He wanted to grab Stephen by the sleeve of his habit and force him to watch the flames, to see how the smoke was being swallowed by the chimney, how the soot on the back wall was growing paler, cleaner, as if the stone were washing itself.

Instead, he kept quiet. He remembered what the Abbot had said in the church. None of us will remember, soon enough. That is the mercy of it, I suppose. Or the curse.

If Stephen and Anselm and Martin could not see it, then telling them would only earn him a trip to the infirmary, where Brother Julian would bleed him for a fever he did not have.

So Thomas sat on the bench, warmed his purple feet, and watched the world run backward.

It was, he had to admit, oddly comforting once the initial terror wore off. The warming room was the closest thing to heaven Saint Bartholomew's offered in January. There was no Prior here to lecture them on desert locusts, no Abbot to remind them of their mortality. Just four men sitting by a fire that was slowly, steadily growing smaller—no, wait.

Thomas squinted at the grate.

The fire was not growing smaller anymore. It was growing larger.

The three logs had been joined by a fourth, which had materialized from a pile of white ash at the back of the hearth. The flames were taller now, roaring softly up the chimney, throwing a bright, dancing light over the faces of the four monks. The room was growing quite hot—almost too hot.

Brother Martin pulled his wet socks back from the fender. "God's teeth, it's warm in here," he muttered, though he did not seem to realize he had sworn.

"Watch your tongue, boy," Anselm said automatically, though his eyes were half-closed, his chin sinking toward his chest.

Thomas leaned back against the wall. The heat was making him drowsy. His eyelids felt heavy, weighted down with the same woollen thickness that had hung in the church earlier. He tried to keep track of the hour. If Compline had been un-sung, and they were now sitting in the warming room, then it must be the hour between Vespers and Compline. The brief, precious half-hour of recreation—though "recreation" at Saint Bartholomew's mostly meant sitting in silence and thawing one's joints before going back into the cold.

Suddenly, a sharp, metallic clang echoed from the cloister.

It was not a normal bell. It was a sound that seemed to start in the center of the room and rush outward toward the church tower, snapping off in a crisp, clean bong that left the air vibrating.

All three monks on the opposite bench stood up as one.

They did not look at each other. They did not stretch or yawn or complain about the cold. They simply turned toward the door, their faces blank and serene, and walked backward out of the warming room.

Thomas stayed on the bench.

He watched the door swing shut behind them.

Left alone, the fire in the hearth gave a great, shuddering sigh—a sound like a bellows drawing in air—and collapsed inward. The fourth log vanished into a heap of glowing coals. The third log followed. Within a minute, the bright, roaring blaze had shrunk back into a modest, flickering bed of embers, and the room began to cool.

Thomas stood up. His feet were warm now, the purple fading back to a healthy, mottled pink. He walked over to the door, pulled it open, and stepped out into the cloister.

The moon was lower in the sky than it had been, sitting just above the roof of the chapter house like a silver coin balanced on a ridge tile. The air was still cold, biting at his bare ankles, yet it did not feel like the dead, heavy cold of midnight. It felt like the sharp, thin chill of early evening, just after the sun had gone down.

From the direction of the kitchen, he heard the faint, rhythmic clatter of wooden bowls.

Thomas hesitated. He knew he ought to go back to the dormitory, find his pallet, and wait for whatever passed for morning. That was what the Abbot had told him to do.

But the Abbot was not here, and Thomas's stomach, which had been entirely forgotten in the excitement of the church and the warming room, gave a sudden, loud rumble.

He had eaten boiled turnips at five o'clock. Or rather, he was about to un-eat them.

Curious—and, if he were honest with himself, more than a little hungry—Thomas turned right and padded softly down the south walk toward the refectory.


This is a sample preview. The complete book contains 27 sections.