- Chapter 1 The Rule of Silence
- Chapter 2 Hands of Stone and Flesh
- Chapter 3 The Arrival from York
- Chapter 4 A Tongue Untamed
- Chapter 5 The First Lesson
- Chapter 6 Whispers in the Scriptorium
- Chapter 7 The Abbot's Gaze
- Chapter 8 Bread and Water
- Chapter 9 The Grammar of the Cloister
- Chapter 10 A Confession in the Dark
- Chapter 11 The Frost on the Rye
- Chapter 12 Broken Vows
- Chapter 13 The Infirmary's Secret
- Chapter 14 Signs of Dissent
- Chapter 15 The Novice's Tale
- Chapter 16 Echoes in the Chapter House
- Chapter 17 The Penance
- Chapter 18 A Storm Over Yorkshire
- Chapter 19 The Voice in the Night
- Chapter 20 The Bell Tolls for None
- Chapter 21 Judgment at Rievaulx
- Chapter 22 The Silence of the Flock
- Chapter 23 Unspoken Truths
- Chapter 24 The Sign of Peace
- Chapter 25 Spring in the Valley
- Chapter 26 The Master's Farewell
The Sign Master of Rievaulx
Table of Contents
CHAPTER ONE: The Rule of Silence
At Rievaulx, the silence began before the light. It was not merely the absence of noise, for a valley in Yorkshire is never entirely quiet; the River Rye always had something to say for itself, muttering over its stones, and the wind off the moors liked to rattle the wooden shutters of the dorter. Rather, it was the absence of the human voice, which, after twenty years, Brother Anselm had come to regard as a blessed relief.
When the bell tolled for Matins, the sound was iron and final. Anselm swung his legs out of his straw pallet, his feet finding the cold flagstones with a practiced wince. Around him in the long, vaulted dormitory, forty other men were doing the same. There was the rustle of coarse, undyed wool, the soft thud of leather-soled shoes, and the occasional stifled cough—though even coughing was frowned upon if it sounded too much like an assertion of the self. No one said good morning. No one complained about the damp, which had seeped into the mortar during the October rains and now seemed determined to stay until Easter.
Anselm pulled his cowl over his tonsured head and joined the dark river of monks flowing down the night stairs into the church. In the gloom, illuminated only by a handful of tallow dips near the altar, they looked less like men and more like a flock of pale, ghostly sheep. They took their places in the choir stalls, and for the next hour, they sang.
Singing was permitted, of course. The Rule of Saint Benedict was specific on this point: the tongue was a dangerous member, prone to vanity, gossip, and outright lies, and therefore must be kept under lock and key, except when it was raised in the praise of God. Even then, Anselm thought, watching Brother Bartholomew across the aisle, some tongues were more dangerous than others. Bartholomew was eighty, had three teeth left, and sang everything a quarter-tone flat, with the enthusiasm of a man trying to drown out a thunderstorm.
When the office ended and the monks filed out into the cloister to wait for dawn, the silence returned, heavier than before. It was Anselm’s silence. As the Sign Master of Rievaulx, he was its chief guardian, its grammarian, and, on occasion, its reluctant enforcer.
He took his usual seat on the stone bench along the north walk, where the morning sun would eventually strike if the clouds ever broke. Beside him, Brother Thomas, a young monk who had taken his final vows only last summer, was staring intently at his own hands. Thomas was still at the stage where the silence felt like a tight pair of boots. He fidgeted. He sighed. When he thought no one was looking, he sometimes mouthed words to himself, just to feel his jaw move.
Anselm tapped him lightly on the shoulder. Thomas jumped, his eyes widening in guilt.
Slowly, deliberately, Anselm raised his right hand, extended his index and middle fingers, and pressed them firmly against his own lips. Silence. Then he pointed to Thomas’s feet, which had been tapping a nervous rhythm against the flagstones, and made a downward, flattening motion with his palm. Be still.
Thomas nodded, his cheeks flushing pink in the grey light, and tucked his hands into his sleeves.
It was not a difficult language, the signa of the Cistercians, though it required a certain steadiness of mind. There were signs for the necessities of life: bread, water, cheese, salt, a knife, a book, a needle. There were signs for the offices of the abbey: the Abbot, the Prior, the Cellarer, the Infirmarian. And there were signs for the things of the spirit, though Anselm had always found those less useful. You rarely needed to ask a brother to pass the grace of God at the dinner table, whereas you frequently needed him to pass the mustard.
The sun began to bleach the mist rising from the river, turning the valley from charcoal to slate. In the chapter house, the monks gathered for the daily reading of the Rule and the confession of faults. Here, speech was allowed, though only in the most prescribed manner. A monk accused himself of dropping a bowl, or arriving late to Prime, or falling asleep during the reading. He prostrated himself on the floor, received his penance—usually a few extra psalms or a day on bread and water—and rose again, returning to the fold of the mute.
Anselm had nothing to confess that morning, which was a small mercy. His knees were aching, and the stone floor of the chapter house was unforgiving. Instead, he watched the novices sitting in the back row. There were six of them, boys and young men who had come to Rievaulx from the surrounding farms and villages, drawn by the promise of salvation, or perhaps merely by the promise of three square meals a day in a lean year.
They were terrible at the signs. They waved their arms like drowning men, or else they made the gestures so small and furtive that they looked like they were trying to scratch an itch without anyone noticing. Yesterday, young Robert had tried to ask for a fresh quill in the scriptorium and had accidentally signed for a boiled turnip. The librarian, a humorless man from Normandy, had stared at him for a full minute before handing him a piece of chalk and telling him—with a violent jab of his thumb toward the door—to go weed the kitchen garden.
After Chapter came the work of the day. The lay brothers, bearded men in brown habits who did the heavy labor of the abbey, headed out toward the barns, the smithy, and the sheepfolds. The choir monks dispersed to the scriptorium, the cloister, or the gardens. Anselm gathered his six novices in the eastern walk of the cloister, near the warming room, where a faint smell of peat smoke drifted under the heavy oak door.
He stood before them and waited until they were all looking at his hands.
He began with the basics, as he always did. He cupped his left hand and tapped it with the fingers of his right. Bowl. He drew his right hand across his throat, palm down, then mimed tearing something in half. Bread. He touched his nose, then pointed upward. Incense.
The novices copied him, their faces scrunched in concentration. Robert, the boy who had asked for the turnip, had a habit of sticking his tongue out of the corner of his mouth whenever he was thinking hard. Anselm reached out and tapped the boy’s chin, pushing his mouth shut. Robert blinked, swallowed, and tucked his tongue away.
For an hour, they practiced the vocabulary of the refectory. Anselm drilled them on the difference between fish—a rippling motion of the flat hand, like a trout in the Rye—and eel, which required the same motion but with the index finger extended, to show its length and slipperiness. It was a crucial distinction, especially on Fridays, when the Cellarer was known to be stingy with the salmon and overly generous with the eels from the stewponds.
Next came the signs for the scriptorium. Parchment was indicated by flattening both hands and smoothing them over an imaginary surface. Ink was a dipping motion with the thumb and forefinger. Mistake—a sign the novices would need frequently—was made by drawing the knuckles across the forehead, as if wiping away a sweat of shame.
Midway through the lesson, Brother Hugh, the Cellarer’s assistant, hurried past them, carrying a wooden bucket. He caught Anselm’s eye, paused, and made a rapid series of gestures: he pointed toward the kitchen, mimed lifting something heavy, and then held up three fingers before tapping his own ear.
Anselm frowned, then signed back: Wait. He turned to the novices, made the sign for book—opening his palms like pages—and pointed to the stone bench. They understood well enough; they sat down and began to mouth their silent prayers, though Anselm noticed Robert’s fingers twitching as he practiced the sign for eel against his knee.
Anselm followed Hugh to the kitchen door. Inside, the air was thick with the smell of boiling cabbage and wet wool. The head cook, a lay brother named Wat who had the build of an ox and the temperament of a badger, was standing over a massive iron cauldron, glaring at a pile of leeks.
Hugh pointed at Wat, then made the sign for salt, followed by a sweeping gesture that meant none or empty.
Anselm looked at Wat. Wat did not use the monastic signs with much grace; his hands were too thick and scarred from years of chopping wood and hauling carcasses. Instead, Wat raised both hands, palms up, and shrugged his massive shoulders, his beard bristling. Then he pointed at Hugh and made a sharp, cutting motion across his own palm, which was not in the official signa at all, but clearly meant that Hugh was an idiot who had forgotten to order the salt from the packmen at Helmsley.
Hugh bristled. He stepped forward and began to sign rapidly, his fingers flying. He made the sign for yesterday, then cart, then rain, then mud. Clearly, the salt had been delayed by the weather.
Wat’s face darkened. He reached for a wooden ladle.
Anselm stepped between them. He did not need to speak; his posture was enough. He raised both hands, palms outward, and held them steady until Wat lowered the ladle and Hugh dropped his hands to his sides. Then Anselm turned to Hugh, made the sign for horse, then Helmsley, and pointed toward the abbey gate. Go and see if they are on the road.
Hugh nodded, looking relieved to escape the kitchen, and hurried off.
Anselm turned to Wat, patted the air gently—patience—and then made the sign for blessing. Wat grunted, a sound that bordered dangerously on speech, and turned back to his cauldron.
Such moments were common. Silence did not cure men of their tempers; it merely forced their tempers into their elbows and eyebrows. A monk could slam a book shut with as much malice as another man could slam a door, and Anselm had once seen two senior brothers conduct a furious, twenty-minute theological argument over the nature of the Trinity using nothing but their fingers, their nostrils, and a piece of chalk.
By midday, the bell rang for Sext, and afterward, the community filed into the refectory for their main meal. The hall was long and bright, with high windows letting in the pale Yorkshire light. Long oak tables ran down either side, covered with coarse linen cloths.
The monks stood behind their benches until the Abbot arrived. When he took his seat at the high table on the dais, he struck a small wooden mallet once against the wood. They sat, and the only voice permitted in the refectory began.
It was Brother Anselm’s turn as the weekly reader? No, this week it was Brother Martin, a young man with a clear, high voice that carried well over the clatter of wooden spoons. Martin stood in the stone pulpit built into the thick wall, a large leather-bound volume open before him, and began to read from the Lives of the Fathers.
"Abba Poemen said," Martin’s voice echoed off the stone rafters, "'If a man keeps silent, he will find peace in every place where he dwells.'"
Below him, forty men ate their cabbage soup in absolute, deafening silence. The acoustics of the refectory were such that every slurp, every scrape of a horn spoon against a trencher, seemed magnified. Anselm kept his eyes on his bowl, eating methodically. The soup was thin, as usual, and lukewarm, as usual, but the rye bread was fresh enough if you soaked it first.
Across the table, Brother Bartholomew was struggling with a piece of gristle—or perhaps a particularly tough leek—and was making faces that would have frightened a horse. Beside him, Brother Thomas wanted the salt.
Anselm watched out of the corner of his eye. Thomas waited until the monk next to him, an elderly brother named Gervase, paused to drink his small beer. Thomas then extended his right hand and tapped the edge of the table twice with his index finger, as if shaking a saltcellar.
Gervase, whose eyesight was failing, squinted at Thomas’s hand. He looked down at his own plate, then picked up his hunk of bread and offered it to Thomas.
Thomas shook his head, smiling politely—smiling was discouraged, as it led to levity, so he quickly flattened his mouth—and repeated the tapping motion, this time pointing directly at the wooden salt dish sitting just beyond Gervase’s elbow.
Gervase’s face cleared. He picked up the salt dish and passed it down. Thomas bowed his head in thanks.
"Abba Sisoes said," Martin read from the pulpit, "'The beginning of all evil is a loose tongue, for it scatters the grace of God like chaff before the wind.'"
Anselm took a sip of his beer. It was weak, brewed from oats, and tasted faintly of iron, but it washed down the cabbage. He found himself thinking, as he often did during meals, about the nature of the silence he taught. People outside the walls—the farmers who brought wool to the abbey, the merchants who came from York to buy it—thought the monks were mad. To live in a house of fifty men and never utter a word from dawn until dusk seemed to them a kind of living death.
They did not understand that words were heavy things. Out in the world, Anselm remembered—though it was twenty years ago now—men used words like stones, throwing them at one another to build walls or break heads. They used them to brag, to lie, to bargain, to complain about the rain. Here, the rain simply fell. You got wet, you dried off by the warming-room fire, and you did not waste your breath telling your neighbor that it was wet, when he had eyes of his own and was just as soaked as you were.
When the meal was over, the Abbot struck the mallet again. The monks rose, bowed to the cross at the end of the hall, and filed out into the cloister for the afternoon’s reading and work.
Anselm spent an hour in the scriptorium, not copying—his eyes were no longer sharp enough for the fine Carolingian minuscule—but checking the work of the younger monks and ensuring that the silence there was absolute. The scriptorium was the heart of the abbey’s quietness. Five or six monks sat at slanted wooden desks, the only sound the soft scratch-scratch of goose quills on sheepskin and the occasional sigh of the bellows from the small brazier that kept the ink from freezing.
He paused behind Brother Thomas, who was illuminating an initial D in a copy of Augustine’s Confessions. The boy had a steady hand, Anselm noted with approval. The red lead was laid down cleanly, without smudging. Thomas sensed Anselm’s presence and glanced up, his eyes questioning. Anselm gave a single, slow nod—good—and moved on.
Later in the afternoon, as the light began to fail and the shadows stretched long across the cloister garth, Anselm was summoned.
He was in the warming room, rubbing his stiff knuckles near the charcoal brazier, when Brother Richard, the Abbot’s attendant, appeared in the doorway. Richard did not need to use the complex signs. He simply caught Anselm’s eye, crooked a finger, and pointed toward the Abbot’s lodgings.
Anselm sighed, pulled his cowl up, and followed him out into the chill.
The Abbot’s parlor was one of the few places in the abbey where speech was permitted with some regularity, as the Abbot had to deal with guests, bailiffs, and the endless legal squabbles over sheep-grazing rights that plagued the Cistercians. Even so, the room was small, austere, and smelled of beeswax and cold stone.
The Abbot sat behind a plain oak table covered with rolled parchments. He was a man in his fifties, thin as a winter hare, with sharp grey eyes that seemed to see straight through a man’s habit to the state of his soul. He was reading a letter, his brow furrowed.
Anselm bowed low, his hands tucked into his sleeves, and waited.
"Sit, Anselm," the Abbot said. His voice was quiet, almost raspy, as if he too preferred not to use it more than necessary.
Anselm sat on the wooden stool opposite the table.
The Abbot laid the letter down and pressed his palm flat against it, as if to keep it from flying away. "This is from the Archbishop’s household in York," he said. "Brought by a rider an hour ago."
Anselm waited. He had learned long ago not to ask questions when the Abbot was in a mood to tell him things in his own time.
"We are to receive a new novice," the Abbot continued. "He will arrive in three days’ time, provided the roads from Pickering are passable."
Anselm inclined his head. New novices were always welcome, provided they were healthy and willing to work. "A local boy, Father?"
"No." The Abbot’s mouth tightened slightly. "His name is Julian. He is the third son of a minor baron—a knight who holds lands near Malton. Apparently, the boy has a quick wit, a decent grasp of Latin, and an absolute inability to keep his mouth shut."
Anselm blinked. "I see."
"I doubt you do," the Abbot said dryly. "The Archbishop’s secretary writes that the boy was originally intended for the secular clergy—perhaps a canonry at the Minster—but he managed to offend two archdeacons and a visiting papal legate within the space of a fortnight. Not through malice, the secretary assures me, but through sheer, unbridled loquacity. He asks questions. He corrects his elders. He recites poetry during meals. His father has paid a substantial donation to our building fund—enough to finish the roof of the new infirmary—on the condition that we take the boy in and teach him the Rule."
Anselm looked down at his hands. They were scarred from twenty years of gardening, cold water, and tallow burns. "The Rule is clear, Father. If he will not keep silent, he cannot stay."
"He will stay," the Abbot said, tapping the letter. "We need that roof, Anselm. Winter is coming, and the old infirmary leaks like a sieve. More than that, the boy’s soul is in peril if he cannot learn stillness. A tongue like that is a fire." He looked up, his grey eyes fixing on Anselm. "You are the Sign Master. You will take him in hand from the moment he crosses the threshold. You will teach him the signa, and you will teach him the silence."
"And if he refuses to learn?"
"Then you will be creative," the Abbot said. "Within the bounds of the Rule, of course. No beatings unless he is actively rebellious, and no starving him to the point where he cannot work. We are monks, Anselm, not gaolers. Show him the beauty of the quiet. Make him want it."
Anselm nearly smiled, though he kept his face composed. It was easy for the Abbot to speak of the beauty of the quiet when he was the only man in the abbey allowed to talk whenever he pleased.
"I will do my best, Father," Anselm said.
"See that you do. He arrives on Thursday." The Abbot picked up another parchment, signaling that the interview was over.
Anselm rose, bowed, and stepped back out into the cloister. The bell for Vespers was just beginning to toll, its deep iron note rolling out over the darkening valley, bouncing off the steep, wooded hills that enclosed Rievaulx like the walls of a cradle.
He joined the line of white-robed brothers moving toward the church. Around him, the silence was complete, unbroken save for the whisper of wool and the distant rush of the river. It was a fragile thing, Anselm thought, this peace they had built out of stone and discipline. It had taken decades to cultivate, like a delicate herb in a northern garden.
And on Thursday, a boy from York was coming to trample all over it.
Anselm pulled his cowl tighter around his ears, stepped into the dimness of the church, and prepared to sing.
CHAPTER TWO: Hands of Stone and Flesh
On Tuesday morning, the frost came down from the moors like a quiet judgment. It coated the grass of the cloister garth in a stiff white fur and turned the water in the lavatorium troughs to a thin, brittle skin of ice. When Anselm dipped his fingers in to wash before Prime, the cold bit straight through to the bone, reminding him that his hands were still made of flesh, no matter how much they had come to resemble the limestone of the abbey walls.
They were good hands, mostly. The knuckles were swollen from twenty winters of damp wool and cold flagstones, and the skin across his palms was as tough and ridged as old horn. A man could tell a monk’s life by his hands, Anselm often thought. The scribes had ink-stained forefingers and soft, pale palms that never met anything heavier than a pumice stone. The lay brothers who worked the sheepfolds had hands cracked by lanolin and wind, permanently curled as if still gripping a crook or a shearing knife. Anselm’s own hands were neither soft nor rough; they were the hands of a man who spent his days shaping the air.
After Prime, while the sky above the valley was still the color of a bruised plum, Anselm walked out past the eastern range toward the site of the new infirmary. The Abbot’s words from the previous evening had sat heavy on his stomach, worse than the cabbage soup. A boy from York. A knight’s son. A boy who had offended two archdeacons and a papal legate before his beard had properly grown.
The infirmary was a skeleton of pale ashlar stone, rising out of a sea of churned mud. Four wooden scaffolding poles stood against the south wall, slick with frost, and a heap of oak rafters lay under a tattered canvas tarpaulin, waiting to be raised. Without a roof, the autumn rains had already begun to pool inside the foundation, turning the future sickroom into a shallow pond.
Brother Gilbert, the master mason, was standing ankle-deep in the muck, squinting up at the unfinished gable. Gilbert was a lay brother from somewhere near Durham, a man who had spent thirty years hitting rocks with iron chisels and had developed the temperament of a particularly stubborn boulder. He did not like monks who came to inspect his work, and he liked the signa even less.
Anselm stopped at the edge of the mud, careful to keep his habit clean, and waited until Gilbert noticed him. When the mason finally turned his head, Anselm raised his right hand, curled his fingers into a fist, and tapped his thumb twice against his chin—the sign for Abbot. Then he pointed upward, mimed a pitched roof with both hands, and made a quick, downward slashing motion. When?
Gilbert spat into the mud. He did not bother with the monastic signs. Instead, he held up four thick, scarred fingers, rubbed his thumb against his forefinger in the universal gesture for silver, and then pointed toward the sky, shaking his head. Four weeks, no money, and the weather is turning.
Anselm nodded slowly. He understood well enough. The stone was there, quarried from the hills above the Rye, and the timber was there, hauled from the abbey’s woods at Bilsdale. What was missing was the lead for the gutters and the wages for the hired carpenters who had to be brought in from Helmsley. That was what the knight’s son was buying. A roof over the heads of the dying, paid for in tolerance of a boy’s tongue.
Anselm made the sign for patience—the gentle patting of the air—and Gilbert snorted, turning back to his wall. The mason picked up a wooden mallet and struck a chisel against a block of freestone. The sharp clink-clink-clink echoed across the valley, a clean, honest sound that had nothing to do with words.
By the time Anselm returned to the cloister, the sun had cleared the eastern ridge, turning the mist over the river into a blinding silver haze. His six novices were already waiting on the stone bench near the warming room, huddled together like sparrows on a fence, their hands tucked deep into their sleeves.
Anselm stood before them and waited. It took them a moment to realize he was there; young Robert was busy trying to balance a small pebble on the toe of his leather shoe, and two of the others were watching a crow strut across the frosted grass of the garth. Anselm cleared his throat—a dry, deliberate sound—and six pairs of eyes snapped toward him.
Today, he decided, they would not practice the vocabulary of the kitchen or the scriptorium. Today they would learn the signs for the body and its ailments, for if the winter was as hard as Gilbert predicted, half of them would end up in the old, leaky infirmary before Candlemas.
He pointed to his own chest, then made a slow, trembling motion with his fingers. Fever. He pressed both hands to his stomach and hunched his shoulders. Pain. He touched his throat, then mimed coughing into his fist. Sickness.
The boys copied him, their faces solemn. Robert, for once, remembered to keep his tongue inside his mouth, though his eyebrows furrowed so deeply they nearly met over his nose.
Anselm watched them carefully. They were clumsy, as all beginners were, but there was a willingness in them. They wanted to belong to the silence. They had come from cottages where five or six people slept in one room, where pigs rooted under the table and mothers shouted over the din of looms and crying infants. To them, the quiet of Rievaulx was strange, perhaps even frightening at first, but it was also a kind of luxury.
He wondered what the boy from York would make of it. A knight’s son, raised in a manor house with hounds and minstrels and guests coming and going from the Minster. Such a boy would not find the silence a luxury. He would find it a cage.
Midway through the lesson, Anselm noticed Brother Thomas lingering near the archway that led to the church. Thomas was supposed to be in the scriptorium, scraping down an old sheepskin for reuse, but he was standing with his back against the cold stone, staring down at his own knuckles.
Anselm signaled the novices to sit and practice their signs in pairs. Then he walked over to Thomas.
Thomas looked up as Anselm approached, his face pale in the morning light. Without waiting for Anselm to sign, the young monk raised his hands. His fingers were stiff, moving jerkily.
Forgive me, Thomas signed, crossing his wrists over his chest. The scraping— He mimed holding a lunellum, the crescent-shaped knife used to clean parchment, and then made a sharp, tearing motion. Mistake.
Anselm’s jaw tightened slightly, though he kept his expression mild. Good sheepskin was expensive. A single calfskin could take days to prepare, and tearing it meant starting over—or worse, leaving a hole that the scribe would have to sew up with linen thread.
Anselm pointed toward the scriptorium, then held up his palm. Show me.
They walked together into the quiet warmth of the scriptorium. The other monks did not look up from their desks; they were too well-trained for that, though Anselm saw Brother Martin’s quill pause for a fraction of a second over a capital E.
On Thomas’s desk lay a large sheet of vellum, stretched taut on a wooden frame. Near the center, where the skin was thinnest, a jagged three-inch tear gaped like a mouth.
Anselm leaned over and examined it. The skin had been scraped too hard, with too much pressure from the wrist. Thomas was tense; he had been taking his frustration with the silence out on the parchment, grinding the knife against the grain as if he were trying to scrub away his own restlessness.
Anselm picked up the lunellum. He did not look at Thomas, but kept his eyes on the frame. Slowly, he demonstrated the proper grip—light, almost floating, the blade held at a shallow angle. Then he set the knife down, turned to Thomas, and tapped his own chest twice. Calm. He pointed to Thomas’s shoulders, which were hunched up near his ears, and pressed them down gently with both hands.
Thomas let out a long, shuddering breath. He nodded, his eyes bright with unshed tears of embarrassment, and picked up the knife again.
Anselm left him to it. He could not do the work for the boy, any more than he could keep the silence for him. Each man had to find his own way to live inside his own skin without making a racket about it.
Wednesday passed in a blur of grey sky and cold wind. The packmen from Helmsley finally arrived around midday, their mules laden with sacks of coarse salt and two barrels of salted herrings for the coming fasts. Brother Hugh, the Cellarer’s assistant, met them at the gatehouse with a relieved grin, though he quickly wiped it off his face when he saw Anselm watching from the cloister walk.
In the afternoon, Anselm was called to the guest house, which stood just inside the outer precinct, near the gate. Brother Walter, the guestmaster, was a cheerful, round-faced monk who was permitted to speak to visitors so that the rest of the community wouldn't have to. He was currently standing in the small, whitewashed chamber reserved for young novices on their first night, eyeing a straw mattress with deep suspicion.
"It's damp, Anselm," Walter said, his voice sounding remarkably loud in the quiet room. "The roof over the porch leaked during last week's storm, and the straw has gone musty. If we put a baron's son on that, he'll have the ague before he's even learned how to bow."
Anselm stepped into the room and pressed his hand against the mattress. It was indeed clammy, smelling faintly of wet hay and mice. He nodded and made the sign for change—crossing his hands and turning them over—then pointed toward the stables.
"Yes, yes, I've already sent a lay brother for fresh straw," Walter said, waving a plump hand. He leaned against the doorframe, lowering his voice slightly, though there was no one else within fifty yards. "Have you heard much about this Julian? The gatekeeper says the rider from York told him the boy talked the entire way from Malton to the Minster without stopping for breath. Even talked to his horse."
Anselm folded his hands into his sleeves. "I have heard enough."
"Well, I don't envy you," Walter said, shaking his head. "I've dealt with plenty of loud guests—merchants, knights, a bishop's clerk once who complained about the beer for three days straight—but at least they leave. You have to keep this one."
Anselm did not reply. He looked around the small room. A wooden bedframe, a stool, a pegs-rail on the wall for a cloak. There was nothing else. No tapestries, no hearth, no books. Just four walls of plastered stone and a narrow window looking out toward the steep, wooded slope of the valley. It was a room designed to strip a man down to what he actually needed, which was very little.
He walked back to the cloister as the sun began to dip behind the western hills. The bell for Vespers would ring soon, and after that, Compline, and then the Great Silence of the night, when not even the Abbot was permitted to speak unless the abbey was on fire.
In the chapter house, before Compline, the Abbot stood at the lectern and read a short passage from the Rule. His voice was dry and steady, carrying easily to the back row where the six novices sat with their knees pressed together.
"Let us do what the prophet says," the Abbot read. "'I said: I will guard my ways, that I may not sin with my tongue. I have set a guard to my mouth. I was dumb and was humbled, and kept silence even from good things.'"
Anselm sat in his usual place, his hands resting on his knees. He looked at his fingers—the crooked knuckle on his left hand where a cartwheel had caught him twenty years ago, the pale scar on his right thumb from a kitchen knife. Hands of stone and flesh. They had built this place, stone by stone, prayer by prayer, gesture by gesture.
Tomorrow, the boy from York would arrive, bringing the noise of the world with him. Anselm closed his eyes, listening to the distant rush of the River Rye over its stones, and braced himself.
This is a sample preview. The complete book contains 27 sections.