My Account List Orders Book Page

Restoring the Painted Ponies

Table of Contents

  • Chapter 1 Dust and Peeling Paint
  • Chapter 2 Return to Cedar Cove
  • Chapter 3 The Ghost of the Midway
  • Chapter 4 An Unwelcome Reunion
  • Chapter 5 Reluctant Partners
  • Chapter 6 Assessing the Damage
  • Chapter 7 Stripping Away the Past
  • Chapter 8 Splinters and Silence
  • Chapter 9 The Lead Horse
  • Chapter 10 Rain on the Pavilion Roof
  • Chapter 11 Gold Leaf and Memories
  • Chapter 12 A Town on the Brink
  • Chapter 13 Late Night at the Workshop
  • Chapter 14 Unfinished Conversations
  • Chapter 15 The Missing Gear
  • Chapter 16 Finding the Rhythm
  • Chapter 17 Old Wounds, Fresh Coat
  • Chapter 18 Beneath the Surface
  • Chapter 19 The Storm Rolls In
  • Chapter 20 Shattered Glass
  • Chapter 21 Walking Away
  • Chapter 22 The Heart of the Mechanism
  • Chapter 23 Apology in Cedar and Brass
  • Chapter 24 One Last Coat of Varnish
  • Chapter 25 The Lights Come On
  • Chapter 26 A New Spin

CHAPTER ONE: Dust and Peeling Paint

The third layer of paint was always the worst. The top coat—usually something fashionable and tragic, like millennial gray or a matte eggshell—came off with a gentle heat gun and a putty knife. The second layer, often a stubborn 1980s beige, required a bit more persuasion with a carbide scraper. But the third layer, buried beneath decades of questionable taste, was invariably lead-based, chalky, and determined to cling to the oak grain like a bad reputation.

Clara Vance adjusted her respirator, squinted through the scratched lenses of her safety goggles, and leaned into the corner of the nineteenth-century fireplace mantel. The heat gun hummed, a low, steady roar that drowned out the late-afternoon traffic on Newbury Street three floors below. A curl of blistering, mustard-yellow paint lifted, bubbled, and surrendered to her scraper, falling onto the drop cloth in a crisp, toxic ribbon.

Beneath it, the quarter-sawn oak was dark and tight-grained, still smelling faintly of smoke and linseed oil after a hundred and thirty years. That was the part Clara liked. Wood didn’t care about trends. It didn’t care about the woman in Back Bay who had paid four thousand dollars to have this mantel stripped so she could, in her own words, "let the natural warmth breathe in the breakfast nook." Wood just sat there, honest and solid, waiting for someone with enough patience to scrape away the nonsense.

Clara’s phone buzzed on the scarred workbench beside her, vibrating against a tin of paste wax. She ignored it. If it was Mrs. Kensington checking on the breakfast nook, she could wait until five o’clock. If it was the landlord reminding her that the freight elevator was out of order again, he could wait until Monday.

The phone stopped buzzing, then started again ten seconds later.

With a sigh that fogged the inside of her goggles, Clara clicked off the heat gun, set it on its metal stand, and peeled off her nitrile gloves. Her hands were dry, knuckles dusted with fine yellow powder despite the protection. She pulled the respirator down around her neck, wiped her forehead with the back of her wrist, and picked up the phone.

The screen showed an unknown number with a 207 area code.

Clara stared at it for a beat. Maine. She hadn’t had a reason to answer a 207 number in six years, unless you counted the annual automated reminder from the dentist she’d stopped seeing in her twenties. She almost let it go to voicemail, but the persistence of the second ring—and the faint, nagging dread that something had happened to the handful of people she still vaguely cared about—made her thumb the green icon.

"Vance Restoration," she said, her voice raspy from the dust.

"Clara? Oh, thank goodness. I was afraid you’d screened me."

The voice was brisk, slightly breathless, and carried the unmistakable flattened vowels of coastal Maine. It took Clara less than a second to place it.

"Evelyn?" Clara leaned against the edge of the workbench, careful not to knock over a jar of denatured alcohol. "Evelyn Hart?"

"Mayor Evelyn Hart, technically, though I still feel like I’m playing dress-up in my mother’s heels half the time," Evelyn said with a short, strained laugh. "How are you, Clara? It’s been ages."

"I’m fine, Evelyn. Busy." Clara glanced at the mantel, which was currently half-naked and looking decidedly unimpressed. "I didn’t realize you were mayor."

"Two terms now. Apparently, nobody else wanted the headache of balancing a budget based entirely on seasonal lobster rolls and parking tickets." There was a pause, the kind where someone shuffles papers on a desk to buy time. "Listen, I’m not calling to catch up, though I’d love to. I’m calling about the pier. Specifically, the pavilion."

Clara’s grip on the phone tightened slightly. "The carousel?"

"The Cedar Cove Carousel," Evelyn said. "Yes. We’ve got a situation."

Clara looked around her studio. It was a narrow, high-ceilinged room in the back of a converted brick warehouse, lit by two tall windows that hadn’t been washed since the Bush administration. Everywhere she looked, there were pieces of other people’s histories waiting to be fixed: a claw-foot table with a shattered leg, a pair of gilded mirror frames missing half their plaster scrollwork, a box of antique brass hardware soaking in mineral spirits. It was a good life. It was quiet. Nobody in Boston knew anything about Cedar Cove, and nobody in Cedar Cove knew anything about her.

"What kind of situation?" Clara asked, keeping her tone neutral.

"The kind where the roof leaked all winter and nobody noticed until the spring thaw," Evelyn said flatly. "The town couldn’t afford to open the arcade last summer, so the pavilion’s been locked up since Labor Day two years ago. When Arthur’s nephew finally went in last week to check the breakers, he found half the ceiling tiles on the floor and three inches of standing water around the platform."

Clara closed her eyes. She could smell it from here—wet cedar, mildewed canvas, and the sharp, metallic tang of rusting iron. "Is the mechanism damaged?"

"The motor’s shot, the wiring is a fire hazard, and the paint on the horses is peeling off in sheets. The town council is meeting next Thursday, and half of them want to declare it a total loss, sell the remaining horses to a collector in New York, and turn the pavilion into a paid parking lot."

"You can’t sell the horses," Clara said before she could stop herself. "They’re 1924 Spillman carvings. Half of them are original hand-carved basswood. You don’t just chop up a matched set for a parking lot."

"I know that, and you know that, and the historical society knows that," Evelyn said. "Which is why I’ve been pulling every string I have for the last seventy-two hours. We got an emergency preservation grant from the state—not much, just enough to cover materials and a modest stipend—matched by a private donor who wants to remain anonymous. If I can present a viable restoration plan to the council by next Thursday, with a qualified lead restorer attached, they’ll table the demolition vote."

Clara’s stomach did a slow, unpleasant roll. "Evelyn, there are plenty of restoration firms in Portland. Even Portsmouth."

"None of them can start tomorrow, and none of them will work for what the grant pays," Evelyn replied. "Besides, you know that carousel better than anyone alive. You practically grew up under it."

"I haven’t been back to Cedar Cove in six years."

"I’m aware. And I wouldn’t ask if I wasn’t desperate. The deadline for the state’s matching funds is October first. That gives us four months to get the pavilion stabilized, the horses stripped and repainted, and the mechanism running well enough to pass inspection. If we miss the deadline, the money goes back to Augusta, and the council bulldozes the pier."

Clara looked down at her yellow-dusted knuckles. Four months. In four months, she was supposed to finish Mrs. Kensington’s mantel, rebuild a set of French doors for a brownstone in the South End, and maybe, if she felt ambitious, take a weekend trip to Vermont to look at fall foliage by herself. It was a safe, predictable schedule. It paid the rent on the studio and kept her far away from the salt air and the ghosts of a town that had watched her leave in the middle of the night.

"I have clients here," Clara said.

"I’ll pay your studio rent for the summer out of the discretionary fund," Evelyn said quickly. "And you can stay at your aunt’s old place—the new owners are in Europe until November and they’re looking for a housesitter anyway. Just come look at it, Clara. One weekend. Tell me if it’s even possible."

"Evelyn—"

"Please," Evelyn said, the brisk mayor act slipping away entirely. "My dad proposed to my mom on that carousel. Your dad used to spend his Sundays oiling the gears while you sat on the brass ring box. If we lose it, there’s nothing left of Cedar Cove except T-shirt shops and overpriced chowder."

Clara didn’t answer right away. She walked over to the window and looked down at the alley behind the warehouse, where a delivery driver was struggling to parallel park a box truck. The afternoon sun was slanting between the brick buildings, turning the dust motes in her studio into a slow, drifting haze.

She thought about the lead horse—a dapple gray stallion with a carved, flowing mane and glass eyes that had always looked slightly terrified, as if he couldn’t quite believe he was trapped in an endless circle. She’d spent an entire summer when she was sixteen touching up his hooves with enamel paint, listening to the gulls scream outside the open pavilion doors.

"Who else is working on it?" Clara asked.

There was a fraction of a second of silence on the other end of the line. Too short to be a lie, just long enough to be a careful omission.

"We’ve got a local contractor lined up for the roof and the electrical," Evelyn said smoothly. "And I’m still finalizing the details on the mechanical and finishing side. We’ll sort all that out once you’ve had a chance to assess the wood."

Clara frowned, sensing the dodge, but she was too tired to press it. "I can’t leave until Saturday morning. I have to finish stripping this mantel before the client comes by tomorrow afternoon."

"Saturday is perfect," Evelyn said, relief flooding her voice. "I’ll meet you at the pavilion at ten. Bring your tools, just in case."

"I’m just looking, Evelyn. I’m not promising anything."

"Understood. Drive safe, Clara."

The line clicked dead. Clara stood with the phone pressed to her ear for a moment longer, listening to the empty hum, before setting it back down on the workbench.

She picked up her scraper, pulled the respirator back over her nose and mouth, and turned the heat gun back on. The yellow paint blistered and curled, stubborn and ugly, refusing to come off without a fight.


By seven o’clock that evening, the mantel was down to bare wood, and Clara’s back felt like someone had driven a wedge between her shoulder blades. She swept the curly ribbons of lead paint into a heavy-duty contractor bag, sealed it with duct tape, and washed her hands at the utility sink until the water ran clear.

Her apartment was a twenty-minute walk from the studio, a third-floor walk-up in Fenway that smelled perpetually of boiled cabbage from the neighbor downstairs and old radiator steam. It was small, neat, and entirely devoid of anything that required maintenance. She had one fern that was clinging to life out of sheer spite, a bookshelf full of woodworking manuals and architectural digests, and a bed she’d bought from a catalog because it required no assembly.

She ordered Thai food, ate it straight out of the cardboard container while sitting on the floor, and opened her laptop to look up the weather in coastal Maine. Rain on Saturday, clearing by Sunday. Highs in the sixties.

She hesitated, her fingers hovering over the trackpad, then opened a new tab and typed Cedar Cove Maine into the search bar.

The first few results were predictable: a tourism page with a photo of the lighthouse taken in 2014, a handful of Yelp reviews for a clam shack that had closed two years ago, and a link to the Cedar Cove Gazette. She clicked on the newspaper.

The website looked like it had been designed in 2003 and maintained exclusively by someone’s reluctant nephew. The top story was about a zoning dispute over a pickleball court. Below that, tucked into the local briefs, was a short paragraph dated three days prior: Town Council to Weigh Fate of Historic Pier Pavilion Amid Mounting Repair Costs.

There was a single accompanying photograph. It showed the outside of the carousel pavilion—a sprawling, octagonal structure with faded blue-and-white striped awnings that had once been cheerful and now looked like a soggy circus tent. The wooden shutters were boarded up with mismatched sheets of plywood. Even in the low-resolution image, Clara could see the sag in the roofline where the winter snows had taken their toll.

She closed the laptop.

The truth was, she hadn’t left Cedar Cove because of the town. She’d left because of a person, and because staying meant walking past the same storefronts, drinking at the same two bars, and pretending she didn’t notice the way people’s conversations stopped whenever she walked into a room. Six years was a long time, though. People moved on. They got married, had kids, took jobs in other states.

She packed a duffel bag anyway—two pairs of jeans, three flannel shirts, her good boots, and a heavy canvas apron. By the door, she set her smaller tool roll: chisels, a Japanese pull saw, a set of dental picks she used for cleaning intricate carvings, and a moisture meter. Just in case.


Saturday morning arrived gray and drizzling, the kind of fine, persistent mist that didn’t warrant windshield wipers on full speed but made everything look washed out and slightly miserable. Clara loaded her bag and tool roll into the back of her Subaru, grabbed a lukewarm coffee from the bodega on the corner, and merged onto I-95 North.

Once she cleared the New Hampshire border, the highway narrowed and the trees pressed closer to the asphalt, thick stands of pine and birch still heavy with the morning fog. She kept the radio off. The hum of the tires on wet pavement was enough, a steady rhythm that matched the mild headache pulsing behind her left eye.

She took the exit for Route 1 just past Portsmouth, following the winding two-lane road as it hugged the coastline. Every few miles, the trees would part to reveal a glimpse of slate-gray water, lobster buoys bobbing like stray confetti, and weathered clapboard houses perched on granite ledges.

It was strange how quickly the muscle memory returned. She didn’t need the GPS to tell her where to turn at the blinking yellow light by the hardware store, or which pothole to swerve around near the old cannery. Her hands knew the curves of the road before her eyes did.

The sign for Cedar Cove was still there, though the painted wooden whale at the top had lost half its tail fin. Welcome to Cedar Cove. Est. 1842. A Working Harbor.

She drove down Main Street at twenty-five miles an hour. It was nine-thirty, and the town was barely awake. A few tourists in bright waterproof jackets were huddled under the awning of the bakery, waiting for the doors to open. The bookstore where she’d spent her allowance on paperback mysteries was now a boutique selling driftwood-framed mirrors and artisanal sea salt. The hardware store was still there, thank goodness, though its windows were plastered with Going Out of Business signs in faded neon orange.

At the end of Main Street, the road sloped down toward the water, opening up into the wide, cracked asphalt of the pier parking lot.

Clara pulled into a spot near the seawall and cut the engine.

The pavilion sat at the far end of the pier, jutting out over the harbor on thick wooden pilings that were dark with rot and barnacles at the waterline. From a distance, it looked smaller than she remembered. The whitewash on the siding had peeled away in long, jagged strips, exposing the gray, weathered cedar underneath. A chain-link fence had been erected around the perimeter, complete with a yellow No Trespassing sign flapping in the breeze.

She sat in the car for a moment, watching the rain bead on the windshield. Her coffee had gone completely cold.

"Just looking," she reminded herself aloud. "Ten minutes, give Evelyn a realistic estimate, and head back to Boston."

She grabbed her tool roll, pulled the hood of her rain jacket up over her hair, and stepped out into the damp salt air. The smell hit her immediately—low tide, wet creosote, and fried dough from the boardwalk stand that had somehow survived the winter. It was the smell of every summer she’d ever had until she was twenty-six.

A dark green pickup truck was parked near the gate of the chain-link fence. Clara didn’t recognize it, though it had the dented bumper and rusted wheel wells of a local work truck. Probably the contractor Evelyn had mentioned.

She walked across the cracked asphalt, her boots crunching on stray gravel and crushed shells. The gate was unlocked, the padlock hanging loose on the hasp. She pushed it open, stepped inside the perimeter, and walked up the three wooden steps to the pavilion’s double doors.

One of the doors was ajar, propped open with a cinderblock.

"Evelyn?" Clara called out, stepping over the threshold.

Her voice echoed strangely in the cavernous space. It took a few seconds for her eyes to adjust to the gloom. The shutters were still nailed shut over the outer walls, blocking out most of the gray morning light, and the overhead string bulbs were dark. The only illumination came from a single portable LED work light sitting on the edge of the carousel platform, casting long, dramatic shadows across the floorboards.

And there, in the center of the room, stood the carousel.

Clara stopped dead in her tracks.

Even in the dim light, even covered in a thick blanket of dust and bird droppings, it was magnificent. The rounding boards—the ornate wooden panels that circled the top of the mechanism—were still intact, their faded gold leaf catching the harsh beam of the work light. Below them, suspended on tarnished brass poles, were thirty-six hand-carved animals. Horses, mostly, frozen mid-gallop with their heads thrown back and their wooden nostrils flared, interspersed with a pair of carved lions, a solemn-looking giraffe, and a single, slightly lopsided sea dragon.

Then she looked closer, and her heart sank.

Evelyn hadn’t exaggerated about the water damage. A section of the tongue-and-groove ceiling directly above the outer rim had buckled, leaving a ragged, dark hole where the rain had poured straight down onto the platform. The floorboards beneath it were warped and black with rot. Three of the horses on the east side were slick with moisture, their paint blistering and peeling away in long, tragic strips, exposing the pale basswood beneath.

"Damn it," Clara murmured, her professional instincts overriding everything else. She walked toward the platform, unsnapping her tool roll as she went.

She knelt beside the nearest damaged horse—a bay jumper with a carved saddlecloth—and pressed her thumb gently against its flank. The wood was soft. Not completely rotted through, not yet, but saturated. If it didn’t dry out properly, and soon, the basswood would split along the grain as it shrank.

"You’re late," a voice said from the shadows behind the center column. "And you’re tracking mud on the platform."

Clara froze.

The voice was deeper than it had been six years ago, roughened slightly, like cedar left out in the weather. It was a voice she had spent a great deal of time trying to forget, mostly with the help of loud power tools and cheap wine.

Slowly, Clara stood up. She turned toward the center of the carousel, squinting past the brass poles and the hanging silhouettes of the horses.

A man stepped out from behind the central housing, wiping his hands on a stained shop rag. He was tall, wearing a faded flannel shirt with the sleeves rolled up to his forearms, and his dark hair was a little longer than he used to keep it, curling slightly at the collar.

Julian Mercer stopped a few feet away, the LED work light catching the sharp line of his jaw and the faint smudge of grease on his cheekbone. He looked just as surprised to see her as she was to see him, though he hid it faster, his expression settling into something guarded and polite.

"Clara," he said.

"Julian." She looked down at the tool roll in her hands, then back up at him, her mind racing to connect the dots Evelyn had so carefully left blank. "Evelyn said she was finalizing the mechanical and finishing side."

"She did," Julian agreed, tossing the shop rag onto a crate of rusted gears. "I’m the finishing side."

Clara glanced back at the rotting floorboards, the peeling paint, and the thirty-six silent horses waiting in the dark. Four months. A leaking roof. And Julian Mercer, standing ten feet away like a ghost she hadn’t bothered to exorcise.

"I need to make a phone call," Clara said, turning on her heel and heading back toward the door.


CHAPTER TWO: Return to Cedar Cove

Clara didn’t stop walking until she was past the chain-link fence and standing on the cracked asphalt of the pier parking lot. The drizzle had thickened into a steady, cold rain that pattered against the hood of her jacket and dripped from the tip of her nose. She pulled her phone from her pocket, her thumb slipping twice on the wet glass before she managed to hit Evelyn’s number.

It rang four times and went to voicemail.

"Evelyn," Clara said, her voice tight enough to snap. "Call me back. Immediately."

She ended the call, shoved her hands into her pockets, and stared at the gray expanse of the harbor. Across the water, the lobster boats were moored in neat, bobbing rows, their hulls slick with rain. A gull landed on the hood of her Subaru, regarded her with one bright, indifferent yellow eye, and let out a sharp, complaining squawk.

"Tell me about it," Clara muttered.

Behind her, the heavy wooden door of the pavilion creaked. Clara didn’t turn around, though she knew who it was before his boots hit the top step.

"She’s on her way," Julian said. His voice carried easily over the sound of the rain and the slap of the tide against the pilings. "She texted me ten minutes ago. Said she got held up at the town office."

Clara finally turned, keeping the chain-link fence between them like a border wall. Julian was standing under the narrow overhang of the pavilion’s porch, his shoulders hunched slightly against the dampness. He had wiped the grease off his cheek, though he’d only succeeded in smearing it into a faint gray shadow along his jaw.

"Did you know?" she asked.

"Know what?"

"That she called me."

Julian looked at her for a long moment, his expression unreadable in the flat gray light. "I knew she was trying to find someone to do the carvings. I didn't know it was you until you walked through the door."

Clara believed him, mostly because Julian had never been a particularly good liar. When they were younger, his ears used to turn red whenever he tried to hide something, even something as minor as forgetting to pick up milk on the way home. His ears weren't red now, just pale from the cold, and his posture was entirely relaxed.

"Well," Clara said, turning back toward the water. "It’s a moot point anyway. I’m just here to look at the wood. Once I give her an estimate, I’m heading back to Boston."

"Right," Julian said. There was no inflection in the word, no hint of whether he was relieved or disappointed. "You always did like a clean exit."

Before Clara could formulate a reply that didn't sound like a defense, a silver Volvo station wagon turned off Main Street and bounced over the potholes at the entrance to the pier. It pulled up beside Clara’s Subaru, the windshield wipers slapping furiously against the glass.

The driver’s side door opened, and Evelyn Hart stepped out, clutching a cardboard carrier with two paper coffee cups and a folded umbrella she hadn’t bothered to open. She was wearing a tailored navy raincoat and sensible waterproof loafers, looking every inch the small-town mayor trying to project competence on a shoestring budget.

"Clara!" Evelyn called out, hurrying over with a bright, determined smile that faltered the second she caught sight of Clara’s face. She glanced past Clara’s shoulder toward the pavilion, where Julian was still standing on the porch, and winced. "Ah. You two have met."

"We've met," Clara said flatly. "Six years ago, Evelyn. In case you forgot."

"I didn't forget," Evelyn said, lowering her voice as she reached Clara’s side. She held out the cardboard carrier like a peace offering. "I brought coffee. From the bakery. Black, no sugar, just like you used to take it."

Clara looked at the coffee, then at Evelyn. She took one of the cups, mostly because her fingers were starting to go numb. "You lied to me."

"I omitted a detail," Evelyn corrected, pulling her collar up against the rain. "If I’d told you Julian was on the crew, you would have hung up on me."

"Yes. I would have. Because that would have been the sane, rational thing to do."

"Clara, please." Evelyn’s brisk, political demeanor dissolved, leaving behind the tired woman who had been trying to keep a dying coastal town afloat for eight years. "Let’s not do this in the rain. Come sit in the car for five minutes. Drink the coffee. Let me explain."

Clara glanced back at the pavilion. Julian had disappeared back inside, leaving the doorway empty. The dark, sagging roofline looked even more pathetic from this angle, like an old animal trying to curl up out of the weather.

With a quiet sigh, Clara walked around to the passenger side of the Volvo and got in. The interior smelled like wet wool, peppermint, and the faint, unmistakable scent of toddler snacks—Evelyn had two kids, Clara remembered vaguely from a Christmas card her aunt had forwarded years ago.

Evelyn climbed into the driver’s seat, shut the door, and turned the heat up to full blast. For a minute, neither of them spoke. The rain drummed steadily on the roof of the car, blurring the view of the harbor into streaks of gray and white.

"He’s been back for two years," Evelyn said finally, staring straight ahead through the windshield. "After his dad’s heart attack. He moved back to help run the boatyard, and when his dad decided to sell it last fall and move to Florida, Julian stayed. He’s been doing custom cabinetry and finish work out of a rented bay near the cannery."

Clara wrapped both hands around the paper cup, letting the heat soak into her palms. "Good for him."

"He’s the one who noticed the roof leak in the pavilion," Evelyn continued. "He was down here in February checking the moorings after a nor’easter, saw the ice damming up on the eaves, and climbed up there himself with a tarp and a staple gun. If he hadn’t done that, the whole east side of the ceiling would have caved in before April."

Clara took a sip of the coffee. It was hot, bitter, and slightly burnt, exactly the way she liked it. "If he’s so handy, let him restore the horses."

"He’s a finish carpenter and a mechanic, Clara. You know as well as I do that carving and painting a 1924 Spillman horse isn’t the same thing as hanging kitchen cabinets. He knows how to rebuild the center bearing and rewire the motor, and he can patch the platform floorboards in his sleep. But the horses? That’s you. You’re the only person within a hundred miles who understands the wood and the original glazes."

"There are people in Portland," Clara said, though the argument felt weaker now that she’d actually seen the bay jumper’s soft, waterlogged flank.

"Not for what the grant pays," Evelyn said. "And not by October first. Look, I’m not asking you two to be best friends. I’m not even asking you to talk to each other if you don’t want to. The pavilion is eighty feet wide. You can work on the horses in the old arcade annex, and he can stay under the platform with the gears."

Clara leaned her head back against the headrest and closed her eyes. The heat from the vents was starting to thaw her cheeks, making them sting slightly. She thought about her quiet, dusty studio on Newbury Street. She thought about Mrs. Kensington’s breakfast nook. She thought about how easy it would be to finish her coffee, get back into her Subaru, and merge onto I-95 South before noon.

"I told you on the phone," Clara said softly. "I’m only here for the weekend."

"I know," Evelyn said. "And I’m grateful for that, truly. Just... look at the rest of the horses. Give me a realistic list of what’s salvageable and what’s firewood so I have something to show the town council on Thursday. If you still want to leave on Monday morning, I won’t try to stop you."

Clara opened her eyes and looked at her old friend. There were fine lines around Evelyn’s eyes that hadn’t been there six years ago, and a streak of silver threading through her dark hair at the temple.

"Where’s the key to my aunt’s house?" Clara asked.

Evelyn’s shoulders dropped an inch in visible relief. She reached into the center console, pulled out a brass key on a faded leather fob, and handed it over. "The Hendersons left the heat on low, and they said you’re welcome to whatever’s in the pantry, though it’s mostly quinoa and expired almond milk. The water heater takes about ten minutes to kick in, so don’t jump straight into the shower."

"Got it." Clara slipped the key into her pocket and reached for the door handle. "I’ll be back at the pavilion tomorrow morning around eight. Tell Julian to leave the work lights on."

"I will," Evelyn promised. "And Clara? Thank you. Really."

Clara stepped back out into the rain, tossed her empty cup into the trash bin near the seawall, and walked over to her Subaru. She didn’t look back at the pavilion as she pulled out of the lot, though she could feel the weight of it in her rearview mirror all the way up the hill.


Driving through Cedar Cove in the middle of the morning felt like walking through a house where someone had rearranged all the furniture in the dark. Everything was technically in the right place, yet nothing felt quite right.

She passed the old brick post office, where the flag hung limp and heavy against the pole, and turned left onto Elm Street. The maples that lined the road were just beginning to leaf out, their branches dark and glistening in the rain. Halfway down the block, she spotted the neon sign of Miller’s Market glowing dimly behind a fogged-up window.

Clara pulled over to the curb and cut the engine. She hadn’t packed any food, and the idea of surviving the weekend on the Hendersons’ expired almond milk didn’t hold much appeal.

A small brass bell jingled overhead as she pushed open the glass door. The market smelled exactly the same as it had when she was ten years old: floor wax, damp cardboard, and the sharp, sweet tang of bruised apples from the produce bin near the register. The linoleum tiles were scuffed in the exact same places, worn down to the gray backing in front of the deli counter.

Clara grabbed a plastic basket and walked down the narrow center aisle, picking up a loaf of sourdough, a wedge of sharp cheddar, a carton of eggs, and a box of chamomile tea. She was standing in front of the canned soup display, debating between tomato and chicken noodle, when a voice behind her made her jump.

"Well, I’ll be damned. Clara Vance."

Clara turned slowly. A woman in her late fifties, wearing a faded green apron over a thick cable-knit sweater, was standing at the end of the aisle with a clipboard tucked under her arm. Her hair was shorter and grayer than Clara remembered, but her sharp blue eyes were unmistakable.

"Hi, Mrs. Miller," Clara said, offering a polite, cautious smile.

"Don't 'Mrs. Miller' me, you're thirty-two years old," the woman said, though there was no real heat in it. She looked Clara up and down, taking in the damp flannel, the mud on her boots, and the dark circles under her eyes. "Evelyn said she was trying to coax you back for the summer. Didn't think you'd actually bite."

"Just for the weekend," Clara said automatically, clutching her plastic basket a little tighter. "I'm just looking at the carousel."

Mrs. Miller hummed, a noncommittal sound that suggested she knew better than to believe anyone who said they were only staying in Cedar Cove for a weekend. "Shame about the roof. Arthur’s nephew is a nice enough boy, but he couldn't spot a water leak if he was standing in a puddle. Good thing Julian caught it when he did."

Clara’s jaw tightened slightly. Apparently, Julian Mercer’s heroism with a staple gun was common knowledge around town. "Yes. Very lucky."

"You staying at Sylvia’s old place?"

"Just housesitting for the weekend."

"Well, tell Evelyn she owes me twenty bucks," Mrs. Miller said, turning back toward the register. "I bet her a twenty on Tuesday that you'd be in here buying cheddar and sourdough before noon on Saturday. Some things don't change, Clara."

Clara followed her to the front, paid for her groceries in silence, and carried the brown paper bag out to her car. As she pulled back onto Elm Street, she caught sight of Mrs. Miller watching her through the fogged glass of the storefront, already reaching for the phone behind the counter. By five o'clock, half the town would know she was back. By Monday morning, they’d probably have a pool going on how long she’d last.


Aunt Sylvia’s house sat at the far end of Elm Street, where the pavement gave way to packed gravel and the houses thinned out into stands of scrub pine. It was a modest, two-story Cape with weathered cedar shingles that had turned the color of driftwood, and a wide wrap-around porch that sagged slightly on the left side.

Clara parked in the gravel driveway, popped the trunk, and grabbed her duffel bag, her tool roll, and the paper bag of groceries. The rain had slowed to a fine mist, clinging to the overgrown hydrangea bushes that flanked the front steps.

The brass key stuck in the deadbolt for a second before giving way with a loud, metallic click. Clara pushed the door open and stepped inside.

The house smelled of lavender sachets, old pine floorboards, and the faint, musty scent of a place that had been closed up for the winter. The Hendersons—a pair of retired professors from Cambridge who had bought the house after Sylvia passed away three years ago—had painted the living room walls a pale, academic beige and replaced Sylvia’s floral sofa with a sleek, mid-century modern loveseat that looked deeply uncomfortable.

Still, the bones of the house were the same. The wide-plank floors still creaked in the exact same spot near the staircase. The built-in bookshelves flanking the brick fireplace were still slightly crooked, a quirk Clara’s father had never quite managed to level out despite three separate attempts.

Clara set her tool roll by the front door and carried the groceries into the kitchen. She put the kettle on, unpacked the cheese and bread, and leaned against the counter while the water heated. Through the kitchen window, she could see the back garden, now mostly weeds and damp mulch, sloping down toward a low stone wall.

When she was sixteen, she had spent an entire July sitting on that stone wall, sketching carousel horses in a spiral notebook while Julian sat beside her, whittling scraps of cedar into lopsided whistles that never quite worked.

Clara shook her head, annoyed with herself for going there. Six years. She had built a whole life in Boston—a business, a reputation, a quiet, uncomplicated routine where nobody knew her history and nobody expected anything from her except clean lines and a good finish. She wasn't going to let one leaky roof and a pair of nostalgic blue eyes drag her back into a mess she had spent half a decade cleaning up.

The kettle whistled, sharp and shrill. Clara poured the boiling water over a tea bag, carried the mug upstairs, and dropped her duffel bag in the guest bedroom.

The bed was neatly made with crisp white linens. She sat on the edge of the mattress, kicked off her muddy boots, and pulled her phone from her pocket. There were two missed texts from Mrs. Kensington asking if the mantel would be ready for inspection on Monday morning, and one from her landlord reminding her that the freight elevator was still out of order.

Clara typed out a quick reply to Mrs. Kensington, promising to send photos of the stripped oak first thing Monday afternoon, and set the phone face-down on the nightstand.


By six o'clock, the rain had finally stopped. The heavy gray clouds began to break apart over the harbor, letting through long, slanted beams of pale gold light that turned the wet shingles of the neighboring houses into sheets of copper.

Clara wrapped a spare wool blanket around her shoulders, carried a fresh mug of tea out onto the front porch, and sat down on the top step. The air was cool and smelled sharply of salt and wet earth. Down at the end of the street, she could hear the faint, rhythmic clang of the harbor buoy, rising and falling with the incoming tide.

She thought about the carousel waiting in the dark at the end of the pier.

She had only seen it for five minutes, and only by the harsh, unforgiving glare of a single LED work light, but the image of it was already stuck in her head. The buckled ceiling. The warped floorboards. The bay jumper’s soft, saturated flank. Thirty-six hand-carved animals, suspended in mid-air, waiting for someone to care enough to scrape away the rot and put them back together.

If she walked away on Monday, Evelyn wouldn’t find anyone else in time. The state grant would evaporate, the town council would vote to tear down the pavilion, and the horses would be sold off piecemeal to collectors who would stick them in the corners of suburban living rooms like oversized trophies.

And if she stayed, she would have to spend four months working eighty feet away from Julian Mercer.

Clara took a slow sip of her tea, watching the light fade over the pine trees. She didn't have to decide tonight. Tomorrow morning, she would go back to the pavilion, take her moisture meter to every single horse, and write up a thorough, professional assessment for Evelyn.

After that, she’d see.


This is a sample preview. The complete book contains 27 sections.