My Account List Orders Book Page

The Jury at Winter's End

Table of Contents

  • Chapter 1 The Last Ferry
  • Chapter 2 Off-Season
  • Chapter 3 Twelve Strangers
  • Chapter 4 The Caretaker's Key
  • Chapter 5 First Ballot
  • Chapter 6 Snowbound
  • Chapter 7 A Crack in the Ice
  • Chapter 8 Room Service
  • Chapter 9 Reasonable Doubt
  • Chapter 10 The Locked Wing
  • Chapter 11 Alibis
  • Chapter 12 Ashes in the Hearth
  • Chapter 13 The Thirteenth Witness
  • Chapter 14 Midnight in the Pine Room
  • Chapter 15 Unanimous
  • Chapter 16 What the Tide Left
  • Chapter 17 Deadlock
  • Chapter 18 The Confession
  • Chapter 19 Cabin Fever
  • Chapter 20 Broken Glass
  • Chapter 21 The Weight of the Gavel
  • Chapter 22 Thaw
  • Chapter 23 Final Arguments
  • Chapter 24 The Verdict
  • Chapter 25 Open Doors
  • Chapter 26 Winter's End

CHAPTER ONE: The Last Ferry

The Kestrel smelled of diesel, wet wool, and the particular kind of burnt coffee that only exists on state-funded vessels. Claire Bennett stood near the stern rail, her hands shoved deep into the pockets of her coat, watching the mainland slip away into the gray drizzle of late February. Behind her, the town of Port Warren looked like a charcoal sketch someone had left out in the rain—all crooked clapboard, slick slate roofs, and bare maples rattling in the wind.

"You're going to freeze your ears off out here, Miss Bennett," Deputy Kowalski said, appearing beside her with a clipboard tucked under one arm and a paper cup in the other. He was a broad-shouldered man with a mustache that looked like it had been trimmed with a pair of hedge clippers, and he wore the expression of someone who had been told to herd cats across an ocean and had decided to take it one cat at a time.

"I needed air," Claire said. "The cabin smells like thirty years of damp socks."

"That's the authentic Maine maritime experience," Kowalski replied, taking a sip of his coffee and grimacing. "Though I'll grant you, the heater's got a bit of a rattle. Judge Brennan said if we lose a juror to hypothermia before we even get to the island, I have to write a report. So don't go overboard."

"I'll try to restrain myself."

Kowalski nodded, satisfied, and headed back toward the cabin door, his boots thudding heavily on the painted steel deck. Through the salt-streaked windows of the passenger lounge, Claire could see the other eleven people who had been plucked from their lives three days ago and told they were now, for the foreseeable future, the conscience of Knox County.

They didn't look like a conscience. They looked like a group of strangers waiting for a delayed flight at a regional airport.

A man in a camel-hair overcoat was pacing the narrow aisle between the vinyl benches, checking his bare wrist every thirty seconds as if a watch might magically materialize there. Their phones, watches with cellular capabilities, and tablets had been collected in a plastic bin at the courthouse two hours ago, sealed with a strip of evidence tape that Kowalski had signed with a flourish. The man in the camel-hair coat had argued about it for four minutes, citing a client in Boston and a quarterly earnings call, until Judge Brennan had looked over his reading glasses and asked if he preferred the resort's mattress or the county jail's.

On the bench nearest the door, a woman in a bright yellow parka sat with her knees pulled up to her chest, staring at a paperback she hadn't turned a page of since they left the dock. Beside her, an older man with a neatly trimmed white beard was fast asleep, his chin resting on his sternum, snoring softly enough that the engine drowned him out.

Claire turned back to the water. The Penobscot Bay was the color of a bruised plum,chopped into short, steep swells by a northeast wind that promised snow before midnight. In July, this crossing was a postcard—white sails, lobster buoys bobbing like confetti, tourists leaning over the rail with their phones out to photograph the harbor seals sunning themselves on the ledges. In late February, the seals had better sense than to be out, and the only things moving on the water were the Kestrel and a single gull struggling against the headwind.

The Kestrel was not a large ferry. It was a working boat, forty feet of welded aluminum with a flat bow designed to push up against the concrete ramps of the outer islands. Normally, it carried mail, crates of groceries, and the occasional plumber or electrician brave enough to take a winter call. Today, it carried twelve jurors, two deputies, a court stenographer'sworth of luggage, and a driver who looked like he'd rather be anywhere else.

"Last call for the mainland," the captain's voice crackled over the external speaker, distorted by static. "Next boat's Thursday, weather permitting. And the weather ain't looking permitting."

Claire smiled faintly. That was Maine in a nutshell: even the pessimism was understated.

She stayed at the rail until the spray began to sting her cheeks, then pulled open the heavy aluminum door and stepped inside. The warmth hit her like a physical wall, thick with the scent of wet denim and peppermint. Deputy Miller—the younger of the two court officers, a kid who couldn't have been more than twenty-five and who kept touching his holster as if to make sure it hadn't wandered off—was sitting by the coffee urn, reading a laminated safety card.

"Everything okay out there?" Miller asked, looking up.

"Peachy," Claire said, taking the only empty seat, which happened to be next to a woman in a navy-blue blazer who was meticulously peeling an orange.

The woman didn't look up. "If you're going to tell me it's cold, save your breath. I'm from Aroostook County. This is practically spring."

"I wasn't going to say anything," Claire said, unzipping her coat. "I'm Claire."

"Evelyn," the woman said, snapping a wedge of orange free with a practiced thumb. She offered half to Claire. "Might as well eat. Kowalski says dinner isn't until six, and I don't trust any kitchen that's been closed since October."

Claire took the orange. It was cold and slightly bruised, but the citrus cut through the stale air of the cabin. "You've been to the resort before?"

"Once. Ten years ago, for my niece's wedding. Place is massive. All white clapboard and wraparound porches, sitting up on the bluff like it owns the Atlantic." Evelyn popped a piece of orange into her mouth and chewed thoughtfully. "Course, in July they had twenty college kids running around in bow ties carrying trays of shrimp. I imagine it's a little different in February."

"Quieter," Claire suggested.

"Like a tomb," Evelyn said cheerfully. "Pass me a napkin, would you? There's a stack by the urn."

Claire leaned over to grab a few brown paper napkins, catching a glimpse of the rest of the cabin as she did. Across the aisle, the man in the camel-hair coat had finally stopped pacing and was sitting beside a young guy in a Carhartt jacket who was wearing headphones—the old-fashioned wired kind, plugged into a Walkman that looked like a museum piece. The man in the coat was trying to make conversation, gesturing with his hands, while the kid in the Carhartt jacket nodded rhythmically to whatever was playing in his ears, entirely unbothered.

At the front of the cabin, near the stairs leading up to the wheelhouse, two women in their fifties were sharing a thermos and speaking in low, rapid voices. Claire recognized one of them from the jury selection pool—a retired schoolteacher from Camden named Patricia, who had answered every single one of the defense attorney's questions with a crisp "Yes, sir" or "No, sir" that had made the lawyer visibly nervous.

The trial had lasted four days. Four days of testimony, crime scene photos that Claire wished she could scrub from the back of her eyelids, and lawyers who spoke in a cadence designed to make ordinary sentences sound like constitutional crises. State v. Halstead. Thomas Halstead, forty-two, owner of a mid-sized marine construction firm, accused of bludgeoning his business partner, Richard Vance, with a bronze cleat on the dock behind Halstead's boathouse during a November gale.

The evidence had been tidy on paper and messy in person. A bloodstained jacket found in the trunk of Halstead's truck. A missing ledger. A witness who claimed he saw Halstead's headlights at eleven-thirty, though the fog that night had been thick enough to chew. And Halstead himself, sitting at the defense table in a suit that didn't quite fit his broad shoulders, staring straight ahead as if the whole thing were happening to someone else.

Claire had expected the deliberations to take an afternoon. Maybe a day, if someone wanted to argue about the visibility in the fog. Instead, Judge Brennan had called them into the jury box at three o'clock on a Friday afternoon, thanked them for their patience, and announced that due to a credible threat of juror tampering—a phrase he delivered with the calm of a man reading a grocery list—and an approaching coastal storm that threatened to knock out power to the mainland hotels, the court had arranged for their sequestration at The Moorings on Cairn Island.

There had been a collective gasp, followed by the camel-hair coat man asking if that was even legal. Judge Brennan had assured him it was, wished them a productive weekend, and handed them over to Kowalski.

Now, here they were, forty minutes out from Port Warren, bouncing over six-foot swells toward a summer resort that had been shuttered for the winter.

"How long do you think we'll be out there?" Claire asked Evelyn.

Evelyn wiped her fingers on the brown napkin. "Depends on how stubborn folks are. If everybody agrees, we're back on the Thursday boat. If somebody decides to play Henry Fonda, we might be there until the lilacs bloom."

"Let's hope nobody's feeling dramatic," Claire said.

"Honey," Evelyn said, glancing down the aisle at the camel-hair coat man, who was now staring out the window with the tragic intensity of a Victorian widow, "have you met people?"

The Kestrel lurched sideways as a larger wave caught the hull, sending a cascade of white water across the side windows. Somewhere near the back, a thermos rolled across the floor with a hollow metallic clatter. The sleeping man with the white beard jerked awake, blinked twice, and immediately went back to sleep.

"Rougher out here than it looked from the dock," Miller said from the front, his voice pitched a little too high. He had gone slightly pale around the gills.

"You'll get your sea legs, kid," Kowalski called from the doorway, where he had reappeared, shaking rain from his hat. "Just don't look at the horizon. Look at the floor. Or better yet, look at your boots."

"I thought you were supposed to look at the horizon," Miller muttered.

"That's for tourists," Kowalski said. "Cops look at their boots."

Claire leaned her head back against the cold fiberglass wall and closed her eyes. She was thirty-four, an architectural restorer who spent most of her time scraping lead paint off nineteenth-century moldings and arguing with historical societies about the proper shade of colonial blue. She had a cat named Barnaby who was currently being fed by her neighbor, a half-finished sunroom project in Belfast, and a mild, persistent dislike of being told what to do.

She had tried to get out of jury duty, of course. Everyone did. She had told the judge about her deadline on the Belfast house, about her neighbor's tendency to forget whether he'd fed the cat, about the fact that she didn't particularly like boats. Judge Brennan had listened politely, made a small note on his pad, and seated her in chair number four.

Now, listening to the rhythmic thrum of the diesel engine and the hiss of the spray against the glass, she wondered what the resort would actually look like. She had seen pictures of The Moorings in old Maine travel magazines—sweeping lawns, Adirondack chairs facing the sea, striped awnings over the veranda. It was the kind of place where people went to forget they had jobs, not the kind of place where twelve strangers went to decide whether a man should spend the rest of his life in Thomaston State Prison.

Twenty minutes later, the engine pitch dropped. The Kestrel stopped pitching quite so violently, sliding into the lee of a long, dark landmass that rose out of the gray water like the back of a sleeping whale.

Claire sat up and wiped a clear circle on the fogged window with the sleeve of her coat.

Cairn Island.

From the water, it looked almost entirely uninhabited. Dense stands of black spruce crowded right up to the granite shoreline, their lower branches stripped bare by decades of salt spray. There were no streetlights, no clusters of coastal cottages, no neon signs glowing through the mist. Just rock, trees, and a narrow gravel road that wound up from a wooden pier toward the bluff.

And there, perched on the highest point of the ridge, was The Moorings.

Even through the rain, it was imposing. It was a sprawling, three-story Victorian structure painted a weathered, ghostly white, with dark green shutters bolted tight over every single window on the ground floor. A wide veranda wrapped around the entire front of the building, its railings bare, its ceiling sagging slightly at the far corner. A tall brick chimney rose from the center of the roof, and from it, a thin, pale ribbon of smoke was curling into the gray sky.

"Somebody's home," Evelyn murmured, leaning across Claire to peer out the window.

"Caretaker," Kowalski said, stepping into the aisle and clapping his hands twice. "Alright, folks, listen up. We're coming into the dock. Grab your bags, keep your coats zipped, and watch your step on the ramp—it's slicker than greased glass. Nobody wanders off. Nobody talks to the deckhands. You're guests of the state now, and we're going to act like it."

The Kestrel bumped against the rubber tires lashed to the pier pilings with a dull, heavy thud. Outside, a deckhand in yellow oilskins jumped onto the dock and looped a thick hemp line around a cleat.

The cabin filled with the sound of zippers, rustling nylon, and the low grumble of people stiff from sitting too long. Claire hoisted her canvas duffel bag onto her shoulder and fell into line behind Evelyn.

When she stepped out onto the deck, the wind hit her full force, carrying the sharp, clean scent of pine needles and cold salt water. The rain had turned to sleet, ticking softly against the hood of her coat.

At the end of the pier, parked on the gravel turnaround, sat a battered white van with THE MOORINGS painted on the side in faded gold lettering. Beside it stood a tall, thin man in a waxed canvas jacket and a wool watch cap, his hands clasped behind his back. He didn't smile as the jurors filed down the gangplank. He simply watched them, his pale eyes moving from face to face, counting them off as they stepped onto the island.

Claire's boots hit the wet planks of the dock. Behind her, the Kestrel's engine rumbled, already preparing to cast off and head back to the mainland before the storm hit in earnest.

She looked up at the bluff, at the shuttered windows of the resort, and felt a sudden, unmistakable chill that had nothing to do with the weather.

"Move along, folks," Kowalski called out, gesturing toward the van. "It's a short ride up the hill, and I hear they've got the fireplace going."

Claire adjusted the strap of her duffel bag and walked toward the van, the sleet stinging her face, as the Kestrel blew its horn once—a long, mournful sound that echoed off the granite cliffs and died out over the empty bay.


CHAPTER TWO: Off-Season

The van smelled of mouse droppings, damp vinyl, and a faint, lingering trace of coconut sunscreen that felt like a personal insult in thirty-degree sleet.

Claire wedged herself onto the middle bench between Evelyn and the woman in the yellow parka, who had tucked her paperback into her coat pocket and was now staring straight ahead at the back of the driver’s seat. There wasn't enough room for everyone’s luggage inside, so Kowalski and the caretaker had lashed the larger suitcases to the roof rack with bungee cords, while the rest of them held their duffels on their laps like oversized toddlers.

"Everybody buckled?" Kowalski called from the front passenger seat, though half the seatbelts were missing their metal tongues or buried somewhere deep in the cracked upholstery.

Nobody answered. The caretaker shifted the van into gear with a metallic grind that made Claire wince, and they lurched forward off the gravel turnaround onto a narrow, rutted drive.

Through the windshield, the headlights cut weak yellow tunnels into the thickening gloom. The sleet had begun to stick to the pine needles, turning the black spruce forest on either side of the road into a wall of glistening, dark glass.

"I'm Arthur," the driver said, his voice a dry, gravelly rasp that sounded like he hadn't used it since October. He didn't take his eyes off the road. "I look after the place. Heating's on in the main house. Water's on in the west wing, second floor. Don't go messing with the valves in the bathrooms if the pipes knock. They always knock."

"Good to know," Kowalski said. "Folks, this is Arthur Pendelton. He's been the caretaker out here for—what is it, Arthur? Fifteen years?"

"Sixteen," Arthur said.

The van bounced over a frost heave, sending the camel-hair coat man’s shoulder slamming into the side window. He let out a sharp breath. "Is there any cell service at the top of this hill? Not that it matters, since you confiscated my phone, but I'd like to know if the building actually has a landline."

"There's a landline in the office," Kowalski said evenly. "And I have the key to the office. If you need to make a call, you talk to me, and I dial it for you. Those are the rules."

"I'm a corporate attorney," the man said, his voice rising slightly over the rattle of the van's heater. "I'm not a flight risk."

"You're a sequestered juror, Mr. Vance—sorry, Mr. Sterling," Kowalski corrected himself quickly, glancing back. "And Judge Brennan's order applies to everybody, whether you bill by the hour or by the week."

Claire caught Evelyn's eye. Evelyn gave a tiny, almost imperceptible roll of her eyes and shifted her orange-scented hands deeper into her blazer pockets.

The road wound upward in two sharp switchbacks, hugging the granite spine of the island. As they cleared the tree line, the resort's grounds opened up around them, looking bleak and slightly surreal in the gray light. To their left, a pair of tennis courts lay buried under a layer of rotting oak leaves and slush, the nets taken down for the winter, leaving only the bare green posts sticking up like fence stakes. Beyond that, an octagonal gazebo had been wrapped tightly in blue polyethylene tarp, lashed down with yellow nylon rope so it wouldn't blow into the bay.

"There's the pool," Evelyn murmured, leaning across Claire to point out the window.

It was an Olympic-sized rectangle set into a patio of cracked flagstones. Half-filled with stagnant, tea-colored rainwater and a floating island of pine needles, it looked less like a summer amenity and more like an excavation site. A row of white plastic lounge chairs had been stacked ten high against the pump house, looking like giant ribs.

Then the road leveled out, and The Moorings loomed above them.

Up close, the building was even larger than it had looked from the water. It was a sprawling, three-story monument to late-nineteenth-century optimism, all gables, dormers, and sweeping wraparound porches. In July, Claire imagined, the white clapboard would have gleamed against the blue sky, and the dark green shutters would have been thrown wide to let in the sea breeze. Now, the paint was peeling in long, leathery strips near the eaves, and every ground-floor window was blind, sealed behind heavy wooden shutters bolted from the outside.

Arthur pulled the van under the wide porte-cochère at the main entrance and killed the engine. The sudden silence was immediately filled by the ticking of sleet against the metal roof and the low, steady roar of the wind coming off the Atlantic.

"Alright," Kowalski said, pushing open his door. "Grab your bags. Let's get inside before we freeze."

They filed out onto the flagstone walkway, shivering as the wind whipped around the corner of the porch. Deputy Miller hurried around to the back of the van to help Arthur unlash the suitcases from the roof, his face still a pale, waxy green from the boat ride.

Arthur unlocked the heavy double oak doors with a brass key the size of a butter knife and pushed them open.

The smell hit Claire first—a dense, unmistakable blend of cedar, damp plaster, old wool, and the sharp, comforting tang of burning birch.

They stepped into the grand lobby, and for a moment, nobody spoke.

It was a cavernous room with twenty-foot ceilings, paneled in dark, quarter-sawn oak that had been varnished so many times over the decades it looked almost black. A massive stone fireplace dominated the far wall, and inside it, a fire was actually burning—not a roaring blaze, just a steady, practical stack of split logs that threw a circle of orange light onto the scarred hardwood floor.

Everything else in the room looked like it had been frozen in the middle of a ghost story.

The seating areas—clusters of overstuffed sofas and wingback chairs—were draped entirely in white cotton dust sheets, turning them into lumpy, silent mounds. The brass chandeliers overhead were wrapped in cheesecloth to keep the spiders out. Even the long reception desk to the right was bare, stripped of its brochures, its brass bell, and its guest register, leaving only a dark rectangle on the wood where a blotter had sat for thirty summers.

"Welcome to The Moorings," Evelyn said softly, her breath misting slightly in the air. "Looks like they're expecting us."

"It's warmer than the boat," the woman in the yellow parka said. It was the first time Claire had heard her speak. Her voice was quiet, almost papery.

"Give the furnace an hour," Arthur said, stepping past them to drop two suitcases near the stairs. "I turned the boiler up at noon, but it takes a while to push the heat through three floors of cast iron. You'll want to keep your sweaters on tonight."

From a swinging door behind the reception desk, a stout woman in a thick gray cardigan and rubber-soled clogs emerged, wiping her hands on a dish towel. She had silver hair pulled back in a tight bun and the expression of someone who had been told she had to cook for fourteen unexpected guests on four hours' notice and had decided to do it purely out of spite.

"Arthur," she said, nodding once. Then she looked at Kowalski. "Deputy. Soup's on the stove. Bread's in the oven. Dinner's at six, sharp. If anybody's late, it'll be cold, and I'm not reheating it."

"Thank you, Mrs. Gable," Kowalski said, giving her his best polite-cop smile. "Folks, this is Martha Gable. She came out from Port Warren on the morning supply run to handle the kitchen while we're here. Be nice to her, because she controls the coffee."

Mrs. Gable didn't smile. She simply gave the group a brisk, appraising sweep with her eyes—taking in the camel-hair coat, the Carhartt jacket, the yellow parka—and disappeared back through the swinging door.

"Tough crowd," the young guy in the Carhartt jacket muttered, pulling his headphones down around his neck.

"She's a sweetheart once you get to know her," Kowalski said, though he didn't sound entirely convinced. He clapped his hands together, the sound echoing sharply off the high ceiling. "Alright, listen up. We're going to get you settled into your rooms, give you an hour to unpack and thaw out, and then we'll meet in the dining room at six. Before we hand out keys, a few ground rules."

He pulled a folded sheet of paper from his breast pocket—not that he needed it, Claire thought, watching him—and cleared his throat.

"First, you are confined to the main building and the front veranda. Nobody goes down to the dock, nobody goes into the woods, and nobody wanders around the outbuildings. The storm's supposed to drop eight to ten inches of wet snow tonight, and I'm not sending Miller out with a flashlight to dig anybody out of a snowbank."

Miller, who had just staggered through the front door carrying two enormous suitcases, nodded solemnly.

"Second," Kowalski continued, "the East Wing is closed. It's winterized, the water's shut off, and the doors are locked. Don't try to open them. You're all staying on the second floor of the West Wing. Miller and I will be in the rooms at the head of the stairs. If you need anything during the night, you knock on our door."

"What about deliberations?" asked Patricia, the retired schoolteacher from Camden. She had her purse tucked firmly under her arm, standing as straight as if she were waiting to take attendance. "Where will we be meeting tomorrow?"

"The Pine Room," Kowalski said, gesturing toward a set of closed double doors to the left of the fireplace. "Arthur's got it set up with a long table and chairs. We'll start at nine tomorrow morning. Until then, I don't want to hear a single word about State v. Halstead. Not at dinner, not in the hallway, nowhere. Judge Brennan's instructions still stand: you only deliberate when all twelve of you are in that room together."

Sterling, the man in the camel-hair coat, raised a hand as if he were in a boardroom. "And how long, exactly, are we expected to stay here if the weather clears?"

"Until you reach a verdict, or until Judge Brennan says otherwise," Kowalski replied. "Now, let's get you some keys."

Arthur stepped behind the reception desk and pulled open a drawer, producing a wooden board studded with brass hooks. Twelve heavy brass keys hung from it, each attached to a diamond-shaped wooden fob stamped with a room number.

Claire watched him read the names off a crumpled list Kowalski handed him. He didn't mispronounce any of them, though he didn't bother with pleasantries either.

"Bennett," Arthur said, holding out a key.

Claire stepped forward and took it. The brass was freezing against her palm. Room 204.

"Up the main stairs, turn left," Arthur said. "Fourth door on the right. Radiator valve's behind the curtain. Don't touch it."

"Got it. Thank you."

She hoisted her duffel bag back onto her shoulder and headed toward the grand staircase at the back of the lobby. The heavy wool runner that usually covered the steps had been rolled up and stored away for the winter, leaving the bare pine treads exposed. They creaked loudly under her boots—a dry, rhythmic complaining that echoed up into the shadows of the second-floor landing.

As an architectural restorer, Claire couldn't help herself. Even tired, cold, and mildly annoyed at the prospect of spending her weekend in a glorified icebox, her eyes automatically tracked the details of the building. The newel post at the bottom of the stairs was hand-turned mahogany, scarred by a century of luggage being bumped against it, but solid as iron. The wainscoting along the stairwell was original tongue-and-groove beadboard, painted a thick, glossy cream that had yellowed slightly over the years. Whoever had built The Moorings in the 1890s hadn't cut corners.

At the top of the stairs, the hallway split left and right. To the right, a heavy pair of fire doors had been chained shut with a length of galvanized steel and a padlock—the East Wing. To the left, a long, narrow corridor stretched away into dimness, lit only by two wall sconces that cast weak pools of amber light onto the faded floral carpet.

Claire walked down the hall, checking the brass numbers on the doors. 201, 202, 203. Behind her, she could hear the muffled footsteps and low voices of the other jurors finding their rooms, punctuated by the heavy thud of suitcases hitting the floor.

She stopped at 204, slid the brass key into the lock, and turned it. The mechanism was stiff, resisting for a second before giving way with a loud clack.

She pushed the door open and stepped inside.

The room was small, square, and freezing. A single wrought-iron bed stood against the far wall, covered with a faded patchwork quilt and a thick, army-green wool blanket folded neatly at the foot. Beside it sat a small oak nightstand with a brass lamp, and across from the bed was a matching dresser with a slightly warped mirror that made Claire's reflection look like it was standing in a funhouse.

The wallpaper was a pattern of tiny blue cornflowers on a cream background, peeling slightly at the ceiling line near the corner where moisture had gotten in at some point. Beneath the single window, a cast-iron radiator sat silent and cold, though as Claire watched, it let out a sudden, sharp ping—the sound of hot water finally beginning to push its way up from the basement.

She dropped her duffel bag onto the bed and walked over to the window. Unlike the ground floor, the second-story windows weren't shuttered, though the storm windows were firmly latched. She wiped a patch of condensation off the wavy, nineteenth-century glass and looked out.

The view was breathtaking, even in the gloom. The bluff dropped away steeply just beyond the back lawn, giving way to the dark, churning expanse of Penobscot Bay. Whitecaps were building out near the channel, driven by a wind that was whipping the sleet into horizontal streaks. There were no other lights visible anywhere—not on the water, not on the distant, invisible shoreline of the mainland. Just gray sky, black water, and the white edge of the surf breaking against the granite ledges below.

Claire stood there for a moment, watching the storm gather strength. Somewhere out there, Barnaby was probably sitting on her kitchen counter, staring at the back door and wondering why his dinner was being served by the guy from next door who smelled like paint thinner.

She sighed, turned away from the window, and went to inspect the bathroom.

It was tucked into a narrow alcove behind the closet—a tiny space with hexagonal white floor tiles, a clawfoot tub, and a pedestal sink. She turned the cold tap. The pipes shuddered, coughed a burst of air, and then spat out a stream of rust-colored water that took thirty seconds to run clear. She cupped her hands, splashed some on her face, and dried off with a stiff, bleached towel that smelled faintly of lavender detergent.

When she came back out into the bedroom, the radiator was hissing softly, beginning to radiate a thin, metallic warmth.

She unzipped her duffel and began to unpack, hanging her spare sweater and a pair of corduroy pants in the narrow closet. On the top shelf, pushed far back into the corner behind a spare pillow, her fingers brushed against something plastic.

She pulled it down. It was a child's bright pink flip-flop, size four or five, covered in a fine layer of dust. Stuck to the sole was a single dried pine needle and a fleck of white sand.

Claire looked at it for a second, then set it neatly back on the shelf. It felt like an intrusion to throw it away—like erasing the last trace of the people who actually belonged here, the ones who came in July with sunburns and coolers full of soda, and left without knowing that six months later, twelve strangers would be sitting in their rooms, trying to decide whether Thomas Halstead had beaten his partner to death with a bronze cleat.

A knock at the door made her jump.

She opened it to find Evelyn standing in the hallway, already changed out of her navy blazer and into a thick, cable-knit fisherman's sweater.

"Heat working in yours?" Evelyn asked, leaning against the doorframe.

"Just started," Claire said. "It's making noises like a dying whale, though."

"Means it's working. Mine's got a drip in the sink that sounds like a metronome. I shoved a washcloth under it." Evelyn glanced past Claire into the room. "Cozy, isn't it? My room's got a painting of a lighthouse that looks like it was done by somebody's blind uncle."

"I just have cornflowers," Claire said. "And a stray flip-flop."

"Well, don't lose it. Might be the most exciting thing we see all weekend." Evelyn checked her bare wrist out of habit, then grimaced. "Damn it. I keep doing that. I don't even know what time it is."

"Probably around five-thirty," Claire guessed, looking out the window at the fading light. "The sky's almost black."

"I'm going down to the lobby to sit by that fire before my toes fall off," Evelyn said. "You coming?"

"Give me two minutes to put on dry socks."

"Don't take too long. Sterling's already down there pacing in front of the fireplace like he's waiting for a table at a steakhouse. Somebody needs to distract him before he tries to organize us into subcommittees."

Claire laughed, grabbed a pair of thick wool socks from her bag, and pulled them on over her cold feet. She zipped up her fleece jacket, grabbed her brass key—making sure not to lock herself out—and followed Evelyn down the creaking stairs.

By the time they reached the lobby, a few more jurors had drifted down.

The fire had been built up, and the orange light now reached halfway across the wide oak floorboards, pushing back the shadows of the dust-sheeted furniture. Someone—likely Arthur, though he was nowhere in sight—had pulled a few of the sheets off a semicircle of wooden armchairs near the hearth, creating a small, island-like seating area in the middle of the vast, empty room.

The older man with the white beard was already installed in the chair closest to the flames, his hands folded over his stomach, his eyes closed. Across from him, the woman in the bright yellow parka—still wearing the parka, zipped all the way to her chin—was reading her paperback by the light of the fire, holding the book at an awkward angle to catch the glow.

Near the reception desk, Patricia and the other woman from the ferry were examining a row of framed black-and-white photographs that hung along the paneled wall. Claire wandered over to join them, curious.

The photographs were a visual history of The Moorings in its prime. There was one from 1912 showing women in long white dresses and wide-brimmed hats playing croquet on the front lawn, while men in straw boaters watched from the veranda. Another, from the 1950s, showed a gleaming wooden Chris-Craft speedboat tied up at the very pier where the Kestrel had dropped them off an hour ago, a grinning family waving from the cockpit.

"Hard to believe it's the same place," Patricia said, adjusting her glasses as she leaned in to look at a shot of the dining room set for a banquet, silver candelabras gleaming on white tablecloths.

"Everything looks better in black and white," the other woman said. She was in her mid-fifties, with short, curly gray hair and sharp blue eyes. "You can't see the peeling paint."

"I'm Claire, by the way," Claire said, offering a hand.

"Patricia," the retired teacher said, shaking it with a firm, dry grip. "And this is Diane. We were both in the second row during voir dire."

"Right," Claire said, remembering them now. Diane had been the one who told the prosecutor she didn't trust eyewitnesses because her husband once swore he saw a mountain lion in their backyard in Rockland, and it turned out to be a very large, very fat golden retriever. The defense attorney had loved her.

"What do you make of all this?" Diane asked, gesturing vaguely toward the shuttered windows and the sheet-covered sofas. "The sequestration, I mean. Have you ever heard of a county putting a jury up in a closed resort?"

"Judge Brennan said there was a threat of tampering," Claire said.

"I heard him," Diane said, lowering her voice slightly. "I'm just saying, it seems awfully dramatic for a marine construction dispute that got out of hand. Who's out there trying to tamper with us? Halstead's been in the county jail since November."

"Maybe he has friends," Patricia said, though she didn't sound entirely sure. "Or maybe the judge just didn't want to pay for twelve rooms at the Harbor Inn during a nor'easter. The state probably got a discount out here."

"The state doesn't get discounts," Sterling's voice cut in from across the room. He had wandered over from the fireplace, his hands shoved into the pockets of his trousers. He'd taken off the camel-hair coat, revealing a crisp white shirt and a navy sweater vest that looked wildly out of place in the drafty room. "They just overpay for inconvenience. I've been trying to get a look at the Pine Room, but it's locked."

"Probably so we don't go in there and start arguing before nine o'clock," Evelyn called out from her chair by the fire.

"It's a dining room, not a vault," Sterling muttered, turning back toward the hearth.

Claire looked toward the front doors. Through the small, diamond-shaped panes of glass set into the upper half of the oak, she could see the porte-cochère light flickering on—a single, weak bulb that illuminated the swirling air outside.

The sleet was gone. In its place, fat, heavy flakes of snow were falling almost vertically, already coating the flagstones and the roof of the battered white van.

She walked over to the door and pressed her palm lightly against the cold wood. Somewhere down the hill, hidden behind the wall of black spruce, the Kestrel was probably halfway back to Port Warren by now, bucking the swells, its crew thinking about hot showers and dry beds.

"Don't get too close to the glass," Deputy Miller said, appearing from the hallway near the dining room. He looked a little better—less green, more just tired—and was carrying a clipboard. "Drafts are brutal around these old frames."

"I was just looking at the snow," Claire said. "Looks like it's coming down pretty hard."

"Yeah," Miller said, glancing out the window. "Kowalski just checked the weather radio in the office. Coast Guard issued a gale warning for Penobscot Bay. Forty-knot gusts by midnight."

"Guess that means no boat tomorrow," Claire said.

"No boat until the storm clears," Miller agreed. He looked around the lobby, counting heads under his breath, his lips moving slightly as he checked them off against his clipboard. "Anyway, Mrs. Gable says dinner's ready in five minutes. Dining room's right through there."

He pointed toward a wide archway on the opposite side of the lobby, where a warm yellow light had just flickered on, spilling across the floorboards.

Claire turned back toward the fire, where Evelyn was already standing up and stretching her arms over her head.

"Come on," Evelyn said, catching Claire's eye. "Let's see what a county-funded winter dinner looks like. If it's clam chowder, I'm eating two bowls."

Claire smiled, shoved her cold hands into her pockets, and followed the rest of the jury toward the light, leaving the empty, snow-swept lobby—and the closed doors of the Pine Room—behind them for the night.


This is a sample preview. The complete book contains 27 sections.