- Chapter 1 The Dictaphone and the Dust
- Chapter 2 Salt in the Veins
- Chapter 3 The Call of the Shape-Up
- Chapter 4 Shadow of the Cranes
- Chapter 5 Whispers on Pier 45
- Chapter 6 The Gathering Tide
- Chapter 7 A Dollar a Day
- Chapter 8 The First Picket Line
- Chapter 9 Bloody Thursday
- Chapter 10 Smoke Over the Embarcadero
- Chapter 11 The Steel and the Stave
- Chapter 12 Men of the Longshore
- Chapter 13 The Sealed Envelope
- Chapter 14 Midday at the Union Hall
- Chapter 15 Promises in the Dark
- Chapter 16 The Turning of the Current
- Chapter 17 Triumph on the Docks
- Chapter 18 The Hero of the Harbor
- Chapter 19 Decades of Iron
- Chapter 20 The Voice on the Tape
- Chapter 21 Fractures in the Memory
- Chapter 22 Uncovering the Ledger
- Chapter 23 The Name in the Margin
- Chapter 24 The Cost of Victory
- Chapter 25 The Weight of the Mistake
- Chapter 26 The Last Tide
The Stevedore's Mistaken Truth
Table of Contents
CHAPTER ONE: The Dictaphone and the Dust
The machine had two grey bakelite knobs, a chrome toggle switch that stuck halfway through its throw, and a faint smell of hot lacquer whenever it ran for more than twenty minutes. It sat on the edge of the dining room table between a saucer used as an ashtray and a stack of yellow legal pads that had begun to curl at the corners from the sea damp that drifted up through the floorboards every night around eight o'clock.
Arthur Phelan had never trusted things with small belts inside them. He had spent forty-two years around hoisting gear that used six-by-nineteen plow steel cable, wire rope you could lay an open palm across without covering the crown of the strand. A machine that relied on a strip of red rubber no wider than a bootlace struck him as an impertinence, the kind of gadget invented by men who kept pencils behind their ears and washed their hands before they ate their dinner.
"You push the lever down to talk, Artie," his daughter said. She was standing by the sideboard with her coat still on, her purse hooked over her forearm like a bucket of rivets. "You let it up when you want to stop. That’s all there is to it. The boy from the university said it’s got thirty minutes on each side of the cassette. If you hear a click, it means it’s flipped over, or it means it’s done."
"I don't need a boy from the university," Arthur said. He did not look at the machine. He looked through the bay window at the top third of the telephone pole outside, where the glass insulators had gone dark green under forty years of soot and pigeon lime. "And I don't need thirty minutes. A man can say what he did in five minutes if he doesn't lie about it."
"Well, you took six months to agree to do it at all," Clara said, checking the catch on her glove. "So take ten minutes. Take twenty. The Local’s paying for the ribbons and the postage, not that there are ribbons in these new ones. Mr. Ryan said they want it before the anniversary dinner in July. They’re putting together a booklet for the hall."
"Ryan wasn't there," Arthur said. "Ryan was eleven years old in Petaluma, stealing eggs."
"Ryan’s the secretary-treasurer, Artie. He doesn't have to have been there. He has to write the checks." She leaned down and kissed him on the temple, her cheek cool against his forehead. She always smelled of peppermint and the laundry soap they used down at the hospital laundry where she kept the books. "Don't sit here in the dark when the fog comes over Twin Peaks. Use the standing lamp. The bulb’s new."
The front door clicked shut, then the outside gate with its iron latch that always required two lifts to drop into the keeper. Arthur listened to her heels on the wooden stairs that led down from the flat to the sidewalk of 20th Street. The stairs were redwood, four-by-twelves laid down in nineteen-ten after the quake, and even after sixty years of rain they still sounded like wood, solid and damp, until she hit the concrete at the bottom where the mailboxes hung.
He waited until the Buick started. It had a bad lifter that tapped three times before the oil pressure came up, then settled into a low, watery churn. When the sound had died out toward Mission Street, he reached out his hand, the left one with the third finger missing at the first knuckle—lost in thirty-one when a sling of Oregon pine shifted on the offshore side of the Point San Pedro—and touched the microphone.
It was heavy, made of pot metal with a zinc finish that had pitted into tiny grey craters around the thumb rest. It was cold. Everything in San Francisco was cold by four in the afternoon unless you had the gas heater going, and Arthur didn't like the gas heater. It made the air taste like burnt tin, and it gave him the dry cough he’d spent thirty years avoiding by staying out of the grain holds.
He pushed the red switch forward. A tiny orange bulb flickered behind a celluloid window on the front of the deck. A motor began to whir, not with the clean, deep hum of an electric winch on an American-Hawaiian freighter, but with the dry, fluttery scuff of an eggbeater in an empty bowl.
Arthur cleared his throat. He had a glass of water on the sill behind him, but he didn't reach for it.
"This is Arthur Joseph Phelan," he said. He spoke directly into the perforated metal face of the microphone, his voice dropping into the lower register he had used for forty years when he had to tell a winch-driver four decks up that the load was fouled in the coaming. "Book number 4114. Joined the ILA in twenty-two, which doesn't count because of the blue-book bastards, and joined again in thirty-three when we took the charter back from the International. I’m seventy-one years of age. My address is 842 20th Street, flat B. My father was Thomas Phelan, born in County Wexford, came out here on the railroad in seventy-nine, died of the dropsy in the old Southern Pacific hospital on Fell Street."
He stopped. The machine kept whirring. The tiny plastic spools inside the cassette were turning slowly, one giving up its brown ribbon to the other with an irregular, jerky twitch.
He released the switch. The orange bulb went dark.
The silence in the flat returned instantly, filling up the space between the high baseboards and the picture molding where Clara had hung three framed photographs of the grandchildren Arthur couldn't keep straight. The room was too large for him now. When May was alive, there had been four chairs around the dining table and two more against the sideboard, and the sideboard itself had been covered with doilies she had crocheted out of white cotton cord she stole from the twine lockers down at the Matson dock. Now the chairs were gone to Clara's house in the Sunset, except for this one, which had an oak back with four spindles and a leather seat that had cracked into a map of grey rivers.
He took a cigarette from the green pack on the table, tapped it twice against his thumb, and lit it with a wooden match. He blew the smoke at the bay window. Outside, the fog had reached the top of the hill at Potrero. It came over the crest like dirty wool being dragged across a fence, low and fast, turning the yellow houses on the northern slope into silhouettes the color of wet cardboard.
"You have to start with the hall," he said to the room.
He pressed the switch down again.
"If you're going to put this in a booklet, you leave the swearing out, or you leave it in and let the priests complain to Ryan. It makes no difference to me. But you don't start with the thirty-fourth year like it fell out of the sky. A strike doesn't come out of the sky like a squall off the Farallones. It comes out of five years of eating beans that smelled like floor sweepings and standing on the stones until your socks rot."
He took a drag on the cigarette, held the microphone against his chin, and watched the smoke curl into the perforated cap.
"In thirty-two," he said, "we had the blue book. The Longshoremen's Association of San Francisco and the Bay District. A company union. If you didn't have their little card in your vest pocket, you didn't get past the gate at Pier 14. And if you had the card, it meant you paid fifty cents a month to the men who owned the docks so they could tell you that you were a free-born American citizen who didn't need a real union. The president of it was a fellow named Ryder who had an office on Stewart Street with a roll-top desk and three hats on pegs behind the door. He had a gold tooth right in the front, and when he talked to you, he’d tap you on the breastbone with his knuckle like he was checking to see if the wood was sound."
Arthur paused. The red switch was stiff, and his thumb was beginning to cramp from the tension of the spring. He shifted his grip, holding the barrel of the microphone in his palm like a chisel.
"The shape-up was at six in the morning. If it was winter, it was dark. The ferry boats were coming in from Oakland, great big white things with two walking beams going up and down like grasshopper legs, and every time one of them blew for the slip, the whole crowd on the Embarcadero would shift toward the curb. There’d be five hundred men standing in front of Pier 38, between the tracks of the Belt Line and the corrugated iron wall of the shed. Some of them had their hooks stuck down the back of their belts, points turned in toward the kidneys so they wouldn't tear another man's coat in the crush. If you had an apron, you kept it rolled up under your arm. You didn't put your apron on until you had the brass check in your hand, because if you put it on early, the boss would look at you and think you were cocky, think you were taking things for granted."
He stopped again. His mouth was dry. He reached behind him without releasing the lever and took a sip from the glass on the sill. The water had the flat, iron taste of the city pipes after a dry spell.
"The walking boss was Johnnie the Roach," Arthur said. "That wasn't his name, but that’s what we called him because he had no chin to speak of and he moved his feet without lifting them, like he was sliding over the floorboards in a bakery after the lights went out. He’d stand on a sugar barrel with a little book in his hand. A black book with a pencil tied to the spine with a string. He wouldn't look at your face. He looked at your knees. If your knees were shaking because you’d been out in the wind since four, he’d pass you right by. He wanted men who were stiff, men who looked like they could carry a sack of green coffee—hundred and thirty-three pounds—up a seven-foot plank without their ankles turning."
Arthur let out a short, sharp snort through his nose that was half a laugh and half a clearing of his sinuses.
"Johnnie had a brother who ran a speakeasy on Mission near Third. A terrible hole called the Grotto. If you spent your two dollars in the Grotto on Saturday night, Johnnie had a mark by your name on Monday. He had a system of dots. One dot meant you bought beer; two dots meant you bought the gin; three dots meant you bought the gin and you didn't ask for change from the five-dollar bill. If you had three dots, Johnnie would reach right over the heads of six men with four children each and drop the check into your flat cap. And you took it. You took it and you said, 'Much obliged, Mr. Roach,' and you went through the wicket like a dog getting into the kitchen."
He looked down at his slippers. They were plaid felt, worn through at the big toe where the joint had enlarged from three decades of dropping seventy-pound sacks of Hawaiian sugar onto his foot when the hoist swung wide.
"I had three dots once," Arthur said. His voice dropped lower, so low the needle on the Dictaphone’s little level indicator barely flickered against its brass peg. "In thirty-one, after the Admiral Dewey laid off her crew. I went down to the Grotto with eight dollars I’d borrowed from my wife's brother, the one who worked the car barn at Geneva. I bought three pints of gin that smelled like turpentine and tasted like zinc. I didn't even drink the third one; I gave it to a fellow named Red who was sleeping under the horse trough near the grain elevator. But on Monday morning, Johnnie the Roach reached out and tapped me on the shoulder. 'Hold four,' he says. 'Number two hatch.' A twelve-hour shift at fifty-five cents an hour. Six dollars and sixty cents. I went home and I gave May four dollars and I told her the company had given us a bonus for the wet cargo."
He released the switch.
A streetcar went by outside on 20th, the old iron wheels howling against the grooved rail as it took the curve toward Church Street. The glass in the bay window rattled in its putty, three distinct vibrations that Arthur had counted ten thousand times since nineteen-forty-eight.
He reached into his pocket and pulled out his pocket knife. It was a three-bladed Boker with bone scales, the bone yellowed like old teeth and worn smooth around the rivets. He opened the sheepfoot blade and began to clean the dirt from under the nail of his thumb. There wasn't much dirt—he didn't do anything now except walk down to the corner store for the Chronicle and sit on the bench by the playground until the wind came up—but the habit was fifty years old. A longshoreman always had hemp fibers under his nails, brown and greasy from the tallow they used to dress the ropes.
"The booklet," he murmured. "They want the booklet to say we were all brothers."
He snapped the knife shut with a click that sounded louder than the streetcar.
"Brothers," he said into the empty room. "We would have cut each other's throats for a shift on the copra boats. You ever work copra? You come out of the hold at six in the evening and your skin is yellow from the oil. The dust gets into the pores of your nose, into the corners of your eyes, down into the crack of your backside until you smell like a rancid coconut for three weeks. You can't wash it out with cold water and brown soap. You just have to wait until the skin peels off like an orange. But we fought for it. We stood there in the rain in front of the Matson gate and we pushed each other into the gutter so the boss would see us."
He clicked the red switch down again.
"Ryan," he said, "if you're having that girl in the office type this up, tell her not to fix the grammar. My father went to the Christian Brothers in New Ross for three years and he had better handwriting than the mayor, but he didn't talk like an editorial in the Examiner, and neither do I."
He sat back, resting his elbows on the oak arms of the chair.
"By the end of thirty-three, the town was full of boys from the valley. Okies, Arkies, men who had walked off farms in North Dakota where the dirt had just blown up into the sky and left the rocks behind. They’d come down to the front with their coats tied together with wire, their shoes stuffed with newspaper. They’d work for two bits a day and a bowl of mutton stew that had nothing in it but gristle and potatoes that were black in the middle. The shipowners knew it. The Industrial Association knew it. They had an office on the fourth floor of the Merchants Exchange Building with marble on the walls and spittoons made of polished brass that looked like church bells. They’d look out their windows at the Embarcadero and they’d say, 'Look at them down there. There’s twenty thousand of them between the Channel and the Marina. If one of them falls down the hatch, don't bother to grease the runners; just kick him into the bilges and whistle for the next one.'"
He stopped to light another cigarette. His hands were steady enough, but the skin was thin, mottled with brown spots like the peel of a winter pear, and the big blue veins on the back looked like the lead pipes under the sink that Clara was always telling him he ought to have replaced with copper.
"We had the meeting in October," he said, speaking slowly now, his eyes fixed on the little spools that kept eating the brown tape. "Not at the big hall. We didn't have the big hall then. We had an old sail-loft over on Steuart Street, three flights up, where the floor smelled of whale oil and rotten canvas. There were sixty men there, maybe seventy. The windows were painted black so the Harbor Police couldn't see the light from the street. If the bulls caught three longshoremen together after seven o'clock, they’d run the paddy wagon right up on the sidewalk and use the clubs on you. They didn't hit you on the head—that made too much blood on the pavement and the shopkeepers complained about the flies. They hit you on the meat of the shoulder, or across the back of the calves, where the bruise wouldn't show through the denim."
He paused, his eyes narrowing as if he were trying to see through the green paint on the lower sash of the bay window.
"Harry was there," Arthur said. His voice became flatter, more deliberate. "Not Harry Bridges the way the papers talk about him now, with the suit and the nose like an eagle and the dinner at the Fairmont with the governor. Just Harry. He had a grey trench coat that had no buttons on it, tied around the belly with a piece of marline, and he was skinny as a salt-cod. When he spoke, he sounded like a lime-juicer with that Australian twang that made every sentence sound like he was asking you if you had a dime for a cup of coffee. But he didn't ask for dimes. He told us that as long as we had the blue book, we were worse than the coolies on the Dollar boats. Because the coolies knew they were slaves, he said. They didn't have a piece of pasteboard that said they were free men."
Arthur shifted in his chair. A twinge of sciatica shot down his left thigh, sharp and cold, like a darning needle being driven into the meat behind the hip. He didn't move to ease it. He had learned forty years ago that if you moved when the sciatica hit, you lost your balance, and if you lost your balance with a sack of grain on your shoulder, you broke your neck.
"Some of the older men didn't like him," he said. "They said he was a red. They said he had a trunk full of pamphlets from Moscow under his bed in that rooming house on Pine Street. Maybe he did. I never saw his trunk. I never cared about Moscow. I had two girls with no shoes and May was cutting up her old petticoats to make curtains for the kitchen because the neighbors could see through the windows from the light well. If a man came along and said he could get us eighty-five cents an hour and a six-hour day, I didn't care if he had a picture of the Czar or the Pope in his pocket. A nickel was a nickel. You could buy three soup bones and a bunch of carrots for a dime at the German's on 24th, and if you had another nickel, you could get a loaf of day-old sour from the French bakery that was hard enough to break your teeth but would swell up in your stomach if you soaked it in water until you felt like you’d had a real dinner."
He stopped and listened.
A horn blew out on the street—two short, angry blasts. A delivery truck from the bakery down on Folsom, probably, trying to get past the coal wagon that still came up the hill twice a week from the yards by the dry-docks. The horse was an old grey mare named Dolly that knew the route better than the boy who drove her. She’d stop at every fourth house whether the driver pulled the lines or not, her big hooves clumping against the basalt paving stones with a heavy, hollow knock that shook the floor under Arthur's chair.
He looked down at the Dictaphone. The tape on the left spool was nearly gone now, just a thin brown skin over the white plastic hub, while the right spool was fat and dark, ribbed like the drum of a winch when the cable was spooled on crooked.
"Clara thinks this is about the dead," he said to the machine. His thumb was growing numb against the switch. "She thinks I’m going to talk about Sperry and Bordoise. They always want to talk about them. The funeral on Market Street. The men with their hats off, forty thousand of them, walking eight abreast behind the trucks with the flowers. It was quiet, they say. Not a word spoken. Just the sound of boots on the streetcar tracks and the band playing that German tune, the Beethoven one about the dead soldier."
He gave that short, dry snort again.
"It was quiet because we were scared to death," Arthur said. "That’s why it was quiet. We’d been shooting at the bulls and the bulls had been shooting at us from behind the boxcars for two days, and we didn't know if the National Guard was going to open up with the machine guns from the roof of the State Building before we reached the ferry. My brother-in-law had a thirty-two revolver in his trousers pocket, with the hammer resting on an empty chamber so he wouldn't shoot his own leg off if he tripped on the tracks. I had an iron pin from a turnbuckle in my sleeve, sixteen inches long and heavy enough to split an ox's forehead. If somebody had dropped a milk bottle off the roof of the Humboldt Bank that afternoon, there would have been five hundred men dead in the gutter before the band could have finished the first four bars."
He took his thumb off the lever.
The orange light went out. The motor stopped with a tiny, dry click that sounded like an insect dying inside the casing.
Arthur sat in the dusk. The fog had dropped completely now, blanking out the telephone pole, the house across the street, the top of the hill. The room was the grey color of cold dishwater. Down in the kitchen, the old Servel refrigerator kicked on with its deep, shuddering groan, the ammonia pipes gurgling behind the tin backing as the frost began to form on the little aluminum ice trays that were always stuck to the shelf.
He laid the microphone on the table. It made a dull, heavy clatter against the wood, right next to the saucer where the cigarette butts were piled up like grey maggots.
"The truth," he said. He had not used the word into the machine. He had avoided it the way a man avoids stepping on a grease-spot on the steel deck of an oiler.
He reached out and turned the knob on the front of the box. The machine didn't have a rewind that worked properly; the boy from the university had shown him how to do it with a pencil, sticking the yellow wood into the little star-shaped hole in the cassette and twisting his wrist around and around until the brown tape was back on the original side. It took three minutes. His wrist cracked every four or five turns, a little click in the joint like a dried bean hitting a plate.
When the tape was back where it started, he didn't push the red switch. He left the microphone lying on its side on the green felt runner.
He remembered the morning of the sixth of July. Not the fifth, which they called Bloody Thursday because the two men died on the corner of Steuart and Mission with the gas smoke coming out of the doorways like steam from an open manhole, but the sixth, when the Embarcadero was as quiet as a churchyard on a Monday morning. The state militia had moved in during the night. They had their tents pitched on the asphalt between the piers, little brown triangles of canvas that looked like they belonged in a cow pasture in Sonoma, and the boys from the valley were standing around with their bayonets fixed, their hands in their pockets because their khaki coats didn't have any wool in them and the wind off the bay went right through them like water through a wicker basket.
Arthur had walked down from Rincon Hill by himself. He had lost his cap somewhere near the grain elevator the day before when the police had come through with the riot guns, and he had an old grease-rag tied around his forehead to keep the sweat out of his eyes, though there wasn't any sweat that morning, only the cold mist that had the smell of burnt tear gas in it, like vinegar that had been boiled down until the pan was dry.
He had seen a man he knew—a fellow from the lumber yards named Miller, who had lost three fingers off his left hand to a circular saw in thirty-two and worked with a leather cuff strapped to his wrist to hold his hook. Miller was sitting on a curbstone across from Pier 32, eating an onion like it was an apple.
"They're done," Miller had said to him. He didn't look up. He had his thumb on the root of the onion, paring off the dry skin with a little penknife. "The Industrial Association’s got sixty trucks lined up over at the Southern Pacific shed. They’re going to run them out under the guns at noon."
"They won't run them," Arthur had said. "The teamsters won't pull them."
"The teamsters are going to do what Tobin tells them to do," Miller said. "Tobin’s up at the Palace Hotel right now having breakfast with the bankers. Ham and eggs. Two dollars a plate."
Arthur had stood there on the curb with his iron pin in his sleeve, watching the boys in the khaki coats try to get a fire going in an old oil drum with some broken dunnage they’d pulled out from behind the freight office. The wood was cedar, wet with bilge water, and it wouldn't burn; it just made a thick, white smoke that went straight into the face of a sixteen-year-old kid from Marysville who was holding a Springfield rifle with both hands like he was afraid somebody was going to take it away from him and hit him with it.
"We won," Arthur said to the dark window.
He said it aloud, but his voice was small in the big room. It didn't have the weight it had had when he was speaking into the metal cup with the little orange light watching him.
"We got the hall," he said. "We got the eighty-five cents. We got the rotary dispatch."
He looked down at his slippers again. The hole in the left toe showed a patch of white wool from his sock, dingy and grey from the floor wax Clara had put down three weeks ago.
The machine sat there between the saucer and the yellow pads, cold and grey and square, waiting for him to push the lever down and tell them how he had held the line at the foot of Mission Street while the horses came through the gas, how he had stood his ground with the iron pin until the police car had its windshield smashed in with half a paving block and had to back out into the middle of Steuart with its radiator spewing steam into the air like a wounded whale.
That was what Ryan wanted. That was what the boys down at the hall wanted for their twenty-five cents a copy. They wanted to hear about the bricks and the blood and the way the teamsters had come down the hill at four o'clock like the cavalry in a picture show, six hundred big bays and percherons with their ears laid back and their iron shoes throwing sparks off the cobbles until the bulls had to jump over the seawall to keep from being trampled into the grease.
Arthur reached out his hand, his three good fingers hovering over the chrome switch. His palm was sweating now, despite the cold. The skin felt slippery against the bakelite knob.
He had the envelope in his bureau drawer, under the three flannel shirts he only wore when the damp got into his lungs and Clara made him put on mustard plasters. It was a yellow envelope, five inches by eight, with the corners broken where the paste had dried out forty years ago. It had no writing on the outside except for a number in blue crayon—34—and a grease mark from a thumb that had been dipped in lard.
He had never shown it to Clara. He had never shown it to May. When May was dying down at the French Hospital in sixty-four, her breath coming in little dry whistles through her teeth while the nuns stood at the foot of the bed with their beads clicking against their serge aprons, he had thought about telling her. He had sat there on the white wicker chair with his hat between his knees, listening to the streetcars on Geary Street, and he had opened his mouth twice, but the only thing that came out was that he had paid the gas bill for the month and that the roof on the washhouse was holding up despite the rain.
"A man doesn't have to tell everything," he said to the Dictaphone.
The motor didn't start. The switch was still in the middle position, stiff and dead.
He thought of Johnnie the Roach standing on that sugar barrel in the dark, with the ferry horns blowing across the water and the five hundred men with their collars turned up against the salt mist, waiting for the little black book to open. He remembered the smell of Johnnie’s coat—cheap wool that had been dried near an oil stove, with a little whiff of bay rum from the barber shop behind the Ferry Building where the bosses got shaved every morning at five while the rest of them were blowing on their fingers in the gutter.
Arthur rose from the chair. He did it slowly, using the flat of his hands on the table to take the weight off his knees until the joints clicked into place with a dry, wooden snap. He walked across the linoleum into the hall, his slippers shuffling against the runner.
The bureau in the back bedroom was mahogany, with three drawers that stuck when the weather was wet. He pulled the bottom one out six inches, reached his hand down between the red flannel shirts and the pasteboard box where May had kept her jet beads and her communion certificate from St. Peter's, and touched the paper.
It was still there. It was always there, stiff as a piece of tin, dry and cold under the wool.
He didn't take it out. He didn't need to look at it. He knew what the handwriting looked like; it was written with a steel nib that had scratched through the paper on the down-strokes, in purple ink that had faded to the color of an old bruise.
Arthur pushed the drawer shut with his shin until the brass pulls rattled against the escutcheons.
He walked back into the dining room. The streetlamp on the corner of 20th had come on, throwing a square of pale yellow light through the bay window and onto the wallpaper above the sideboard. The wallpaper was twenty years old, embossed with brown acorns that had lost their gilt, but in the yellow light they looked like greasy thumbprints against the plaster.
He sat down again in the oak chair. He took the pot-metal microphone in his left hand, the thumb resting on the cold chrome toggle.
"You want to know about the shape-up," he said, and he pushed the lever down until the spring bit into his flesh. The orange eye flickered on, small and sharp in the dark room, and the little rubber belt began its dry, circular scuffling inside the grey box. "I'll tell you about the shape-up. But you have to listen to the whole of it, or you don't listen at all."
CHAPTER TWO: Salt in the Veins
The air down on the Embarcadero didn't belong to the city. It belonged to the ships, and the ships brought whatever they had been sitting in for the last three weeks—copra from the islands that smelled like dead cows baked in coconut oil, green hide cargo from the River Plate that made your teeth itch when the wind came off the hatch, or Douglas fir from Puget Sound that smelled clean enough until you got down into the lower hold where the bilge water had been sitting in the limbers since Tacoma.
Arthur Phelan leaned back in his chair, watching the orange bulb on the Dictaphone stay steady. The motor had settled into its dry rhythm, like a beetle trapped behind the baseboard.
"You had to get the salt out of your ears before you could hear what a man was saying to you," Arthur said into the cup. "If you came off a two-day stretch on the grain ships, you had a crust in the corners of your eyes like dried brine. You’d go home and sit in the zinc tub in the kitchen, and May would take a stiff scrubbing brush to your shoulder blades until the skin came off in red ribbons, but the next morning you’d wake up and the sheet would still be stuck to your back from the tallow."
He shifted his weight, listening to the small floorboard squeak near the corner of the sideboard.
"My father came off the coal schuchers in eighty-two," he continued, his voice steadying as the rhythm of the dictation took hold. "He had hands the size of spade heads, with no nails left on the middle fingers because they’d been crushed off in the coal buckets at Pier 15. He used to tell me that a man who worked the waterfront wasn't a man at all; he was just half a horse that had learned how to swear. He didn't want me on the docks. He had me down at the Southern Pacific shops on Townsend Street when I was fourteen, wiping grease off the side-rods of the ten-wheelers with a piece of oily waste. But the shops paid four dollars a week, and a boy on the grain docks could make eight if he didn't mind the dust settling in his lungs until he spit black for three days after the ship sailed."
Arthur paused, reaching for the pack of cigarettes. He lit one with his left hand, keeping his right thumb glued to the red toggle switch. The smoke drifted into the beam of the streetlamp outside, turning pale blue as it passed through the cold glass.
"By nineteen-fourteen, I had five years in," he said. "I was twenty-three years old, and I thought I had shoulders like iron. I could take a barrel of lard—three hundred and sixty pounds—and roll it up a twelve-foot plank with one hand on the chime and one hand on the belly, and I didn't need a breather when I got to the top. That was before the winch-drivers got fast. In those days, the gear was steam, old wooden deck-winches with single drums that groaned like a bull in a bog every time you took a strain on the fall. The drivers were old men who had come out of the sailing ships. They didn't rush you. If a sling swung near the coaming, they’d hold it there hanging in the air while you stepped out of the way under the deckhead. They knew what a lump of oak did to a man’s ribs if it caught him against the bulkhead."
He blew a thin line of smoke toward the ceiling molding.
"Then the companies started putting in the friction winches," he said. "Electric stuff that didn't make a sound until the hook hit the hatch cover. You couldn't hear them coming. You’d be down in the wing, stowing boxes of canned salmon from Alaska—forty-eight tall cans to the case, six cases to the tier—and suddenly the hatch opening would go dark because three tons of freight was dropping straight down the trunk without so much as a whistle from the deck-man."
He stopped and listened to the silence of the house. In the small bedroom at the back, the water pipe gave its faint, familiar shudder as someone in the flat below turned off a faucet.
"That was when the blue book started coming around," Arthur said, his voice dropping an octave. "Not the big blue book of thirty-two, but the first trial they had after the nineteen-nineteen lockout. The owners called it the 'Maintenance of Harmony.' That was the phrase they used on the placards they nailed up outside the gate at Pier 18. Harmony. It meant that if you didn't take your hat off when the superintendent walked past the gangway, you found your name written on the blackboard in the office under the header: 'Not Required.' And when you were 'Not Required' on the Embarcadero, it meant you didn't buy bread at the grocer on 4th Street unless your wife had a ring left to give to the pawnshop."
He took his thumb off the switch. The orange light went out, and the small room seemed to collapse inward, narrowing down to the space between his chair and the dark glass of the window.
He looked down at his shoes. They were old, soft leather with elastic gussets at the sides that had stretched out until they hung loose around his ankles. His feet were always cold now. Down on the waterfront, forty years ago, you wore two pairs of heavy wool socks from the army surplus store on Howard Street, and even then, if you were standing on the concrete apron at Pier 41 while the north wind came off the Straits, the cold would creep up through the leather soles until your kneecaps felt like they were filled with crushed ice.
"The union wasn't much then," he said to the empty room. "It was just a bunch of old Irishmen and a few Swedes who sat in the back of a pool room on Mission Street and argued about the nineteen-one strike. They had a banner with gold fringe that had been eaten by moths until you couldn't read the motto, and a brass seal that weighed six pounds that the treasurer kept under his mattress in a boarding house on Folsom."
He reached out and clicked the red switch back down.
"In twenty-six," he told the Dictaphone, "we had the California. She was a five-masted schooner, one of the last of the timber craft that came down from Grays Harbor with two million feet of Douglas fir stacked five tiers high on her main deck. She had a list to port that made her look like she was trying to crawl under the pier to get out of the rain. The wood was wet, heavy as green granite, and every stick of it had to be unslung by hand because the winches couldn't take the weight over the rail."
He took a long drag from his cigarette, the tip glowing bright orange in the gloom of the dining room.
"We worked sixteen hours on her," he said. "Sixteen hours straight, from six in the morning until ten at night, with thirty minutes at noon for a bucket of cold tea and a piece of salt beef that was mostly fat and gristle. A boy named Moran—little Jimmy Moran from St. Anthony's parish—was working the off-shore side with me. He was seventeen, thin as a rail, with ears that stuck out through his cap like cabbage leaves. He was trying to clear a ten-by-ten timber that had jammed under the rail cap."
Arthur’s thumb tightened on the toggle switch until the chrome bit into the seam of his skin.
"The sling didn't break," he said flatly. "The sling was five-inch manila, fresh from the rope-walk in San Jose. But the guy-line on the boom slipped off the cleat because the mate had used a wet hitch that wouldn't hold in the grease. The whole deck-load shifted about four inches. Just four inches. That was all it took. It didn't make a sound—just a kind of heavy thump, like a sack of flour dropping onto a wooden floor."
He stopped again. The Dictaphone whirred on, registering the low, dry rattle of his breath.
"It caught Jimmy against the deck-house," Arthur said. "It didn't kill him right away. He just stood there with his arms pinned to his sides, looking at me with his eyes wide open, like he was waiting for me to take the timber off him. I put my shoulder against it. I was twenty-six years old then, and I thought I was strong enough to move a house. I pushed until the muscles in my thighs went soft like lard, but the timber didn't budge an eighth of an inch. It had two hundred tons of Oregon fir behind it."
He let out a short, rough breath.
"The walking boss—it was an old fellow named MacIntyre who had a wooden leg from the Klondike trade—came over the top of the stack with his pipe in his mouth. He looked down at Jimmy, then he looked at me. 'Don't strain yourself, Phelan,' he says. 'Get the crowbar out of the locker.' It took twenty minutes to find the bar because the locker was locked and the key was in the tally-clerk's coat down at the office. By the time we got Jimmy out, his tongue was out of his mouth and he was the color of a wet slate."
Arthur reached behind him and took another sip of the flat water from the glass on the window sill.
"MacIntyre didn't stop the ship," he said. "He didn't even drop the hook into the hatch. He just walked down to the pier head and shouted for another boy from the line outside the gate. There were eighty men standing there in the rain, and three of them jumped for the gangway before Jimmy’s body was even off the hatch cover. The boy who got the job was Jimmy's cousin, a kid named Eddie who lived in the same flat on 18th Street. He took Jimmy's hook out of his belt while Jimmy was lying on the tarpaulin, wiped the blood off the point on his trousers, and went straight into the hold."
He leaned closer to the perforated cap of the microphone, his voice dropping into a raspy whisper.
"That was the waterfront," he said. "That was what they want me to put in the booklet. They want me to say it was all hardship and glory, but it wasn't glory at all. It was just hunger. If Eddie hadn't taken the hook, his mother wouldn't have had the two dollars for the coal man on Tuesday. We all knew it. Jimmy would have done the same thing if Eddie had been the one under the timber. You didn't hate the man who took your place; you hated the man who didn't give you the bar when you needed it."
He released the switch.
The silence returned to the flat, heavy and grey. Outside, the fog had thickened until the streetlamp was just a greasy yellow smudge in the dark. The house was quiet now, the way it always was between five and six, before the people down on the first floor came home from the laundry and turned on the radio to listen to the news from Europe.
Arthur sat still for a long time, his hands resting on the edge of the dining room table. He could feel the pulse in his thumb, a small, stubborn beat that matched the slow ticking of the clock in the kitchen.
He thought of the envelope in the mahogany bureau. It had been thirty-four years since he had put it there, but he could still remember the feel of the paper—thick, cream-colored stationery that had come from an office with a carpet on the floor. It didn't smell of bilge water or copra; it smelled of cedar wood and expensive cigars, the kind the superintendents smoked when they came down to the dock to watch the silk ships come in from Yokohama.
"You can't write a history out of a book," he said to the empty room. "A book only tells you what somebody wanted you to know after the work was done."
He reached out and clicked the red switch back down. The tiny orange light flickered to life again behind its scratched celluloid window.
"By thirty," he said into the microphone, "the city had changed. The old steam-schooners were going to the scrap-yards in Oakland, and the big steel freighters were coming in from New York and Liverpool. They had three hatches forward and two aft, with steel coamings five feet high that you had to climb over every time you went down into the hold. Everything was bigger—the loads were bigger, the slings were longer, and the bosses were tighter with the nickel."
He paused, his left index finger tracing the line of a scar that ran from his wrist down to the base of his thumb—a gray, shiny furrow left by an iron hoop off a sugar barrel in twenty-nine.
"We had the 'Blue Book' tight around our necks by then," he said. "If you wanted to work on Pier 30, you had to have your dues paid up to date in the company union, and you had to buy your overalls at the store on Steuart Street that was owned by the superintendent's brother-in-law. If you bought your pants at Montgomery Ward's, the walking boss would look at the buttons on your fly and say, 'You look pretty fancy for a lump, Phelan. Go on home and see if Montgomery Ward's got a job for you.'"
He gave his short, dry snort.
"I bought four pairs of pants from that store," he said. "They were made of cheap denim that split down the seat the first time you squatted over a load of hide-bark, but you wore them until they fell off your hips because if you didn't, you were on the stones for a month. And being on the stones in thirty-one meant you sat on the benches in Portsmouth Square with the old chinamen and watched the streetcars go by until your belly stuck to your backbone."
He shifted his position in the chair, his thigh giving a dull, familiar ache where the damp had settled into the bone.
"My wife, May, she didn't complain much," he said softly. "She was a small woman from County Clare, with hair so dark it looked blue when the sun hit it in the morning. She’d take a bone from the soup-kitchen down on Howard Street—a beef knuckle that had already been boiled twice by the Sisters of Mercy—and she’d put it in a pot with two onions and a turnip she’d picked up off the street where the vegetable wagons turned off the bridge. She’d boil it for five hours until the water was grey, and then she’d serve it to the girls with pieces of fried bread. She called it 'dock soup.' She never let on to the children that there wasn't any meat in it."
He stopped, his mouth twitching slightly at the corner.
"One night," he said, "it was November of thirty-two, cold as a dead man's foot and the rain coming down sideways off the bay. I came home with seventy-five cents. It was all I had after eleven hours on a coal barge off Pier 43. My hands were so swollen from the shovel handle that I couldn't unbutton my coat. May had to take a pair of scissors and cut the twine that held my cuffs together."
He looked directly at the orange light, his eyes narrowing as if he could see the tiny spools turning inside the casing.
"She looked at the three quarters lying on the table," he said. "She didn't pick them up. She just stood there by the stove with her hands wrapped in her apron to keep them warm. 'Artie,' she says to me, 'is this what we're going to have for the rest of our lives? Three quarters and a bucket of coal dust?'"
Arthur cleared his throat, a hard, dry sound that made the Dictaphone's level indicator twitch sharply toward the red mark.
"I didn't answer her," he said. "I couldn't. Because I knew that if I told her the truth, I’d have to tell her that I’d signed the blue-book pledge that very afternoon down at Ryder’s office. I’d signed a paper that said I wouldn't belong to any organization that wasn't approved by the shipowners' committee. I’d signed it so I could get that seventy-five cents. I’d signed it while three hundred men were standing outside in the rain, calling us scab bastards through the wire fence."
He paused, letting the silence fill the interval while the brown tape slowly wound itself onto the right spool.
"They were right," he whispered to the metal cap. "We were bastards. Every one of us who signed that paper was a bastard. We did it because we had children with no soles on their shoes and wives who were boiling old bones for dinner. But we hated the men who made us sign it more than we hated the cold, and we hated ourselves most of all."
He reached out his hand, his thumb hovering over the toggle switch.
"That was the salt in the veins," he said. "It wasn't the sea water. It was the bitterness that went down so deep into a man's blood that he couldn't wash it out with whiskey, and he couldn't talk it out in a union hall, and he couldn't forget it even when he was seventy-one years old and sitting in a quiet room with a machine that cost thirty dollars."
He snapped the switch up. The light went out.
The grey light in the dining room had turned almost black now. The window showed only the dark outline of the bay hill and the long, thin line of the streetlamp's reflection wet on the pavement below.
Arthur sat in the darkness for several minutes without moving. His left hand was cold where it rested on the oilcloth table cover, but he didn't draw it back. He listened to the city—the distant rumble of a switch-engine down on the Western Pacific tracks, the high, thin whistle of a tugboat rounding the point at Black Point, and the low, continuous churn of the oil heater in the flat next door.
After a long time, he got up from the table. He didn't turn on the standing lamp Clara had mentioned. He moved through the dark flat by touch, his hand sliding along the edge of the sideboard, past the three framed photographs of the grandchildren he didn't know, and into the narrow hallway that led to the back bedroom.
He opened the mahogany bureau's bottom drawer. The smell of red flannel and dry cedar came out into the cold room, thick and familiar. He reached down into the corner, behind the pasteboard box, and touched the yellow envelope again.
He pulled it out this time. It was light, almost weightless, like a dried leaf that had survived the winter under a pile of boards.
He carried it back to the dining room, holding it by the top edge between his thumb and index finger as if it were covered in grease. He didn't turn on the light to look at it. He laid it flat on the table, right next to the Dictaphone, where the yellow beam from the streetlamp fell across its corner.
The number 34 showed clearly in the pale light, the blue crayon thick and rough against the aged paper.
Arthur sat down again in his oak chair. He picked up the pot-metal microphone, his thumb finding the chrome toggle switch without looking.
"Chapter Three," he said to the small orange light when it came back on. "You put it down as 'The Call of the Shape-Up.' But if you want to know what it really was, you call it the morning we sold our souls for a copper check and thought we were doing a favor for our families."
He closed his eyes, his voice steadying into the rhythmic cadence of a man who has finally stopped trying to remember the lies he told forty years ago.
"It started at five o'clock," he said into the darkness. "The stars were still out over the bay, but they didn't look like stars; they looked like small holes burnt in an old canvas sail..."
This is a sample preview. The complete book contains 27 sections.